Gender diversity and management aspirations in public sector workplaces in Denmark

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to explore the relationship between workplace gender diversity among peers and management aspirations among male and female employees. It focuses on whether gender diversity influences men and women’s management aspirations. Design/methodology/approach The study builds on cross-sectional survey data from the Danish public sector. Findings Results shows that in mixed-gender workplaces, male employees are less likely to express management aspirations than male employees in mono-gender workplaces, but female employees in mixed-gender workplaces express management aspirations to the same – low – degree as female employees in mono-gender workplaces. All in all, the findings show that gender differences in career aspirations are not just a matter of individual preferences and/or macro-structural factors but also a matter of factors at organizational level. The findings suggest both positive and negative implications of gender diversity, and hence problematize a – rather common – simplistic celebration of gender diversity. First of all, gender diversity seems to counteract the fertilization of rigid stereotypes of men and hence prevents some men from being pushed into management positions and a career ladder they perhaps do not want to be placed at in the first place. Research limitations/implications Because of the chosen research approach, the research results may lack generalizability. Therefore, researchers are encouraged to test the proposed propositions further. Practical implications The findings seem to identify that the challenge of secure a large and qualified pool of potential managers might be even extra challeging for managers in gender-diverse organisations. Originality/value A more nuanced view of the implications of gender diversity based on a basic argument of gender-asymmetry. Furthermore, the study are build on a unique dataset that allows to study the implications of gender diversity across a wide range of occupational setting and hence control for occupation specific characteristics.

Gender stereotyping and self-stereotyping among Danish managers

“…2.2 Self-stereotyping attitudes of managers Stereotypes may also operate by being prescriptive, that is, inform people how a member of their group should be like or behave (Kanter, 1977;Heilman, 2001;Bertrand, 2020). It is especially the prescriptive nature of stereotypes that are important for the question we are dealing with, as prescriptive stereotypes can influence the "supply side" of the managerial labor market and employees' managerial career aspirations (Correll, 2004;Nielsen and Madsen, 2019). Two mechanisms are important here.…”

The balance between status quo and change when minorities try to access top ranks: a tale about women achieving professorship

“…Literature built on this approach stressed that gender imbalance creates a hostile environment because women are expected to fit into the (masculine) organisational culture. Nielsen and Madsen (2019) showed that today women still find themselves in token positions, which has detrimental effects on women's career aspirations.…”

Corporate lawyers in the USA: pathway to gender parity?

“…Finally, women's integration into an organization or industry also enhances that available labor pool for senior roles. Women's representation within the industry increases their access to lower level managerial and supervisory roles (Huffman, 2016) and may reduce men's expectation of occupying leadership positions (Nielsen and Madsen, 2019). Lower level leadership opportunities can provide a pipeline of qualified women for senior leadership ranks.…”