Gender Identity and Relative Income within Households *

Abstract

We examine causes and consequences of relative income within households. We show that the distribution of the share of income earned by the wife exhibits a sharp drop to the right of 1 2 , where the wife's income exceeds the husband's income. We argue that this pattern is best explained by gender identity norms, which induce an aversion to a situation where the wife earns more than her husband. We present evidence that this aversion also impacts marriage formation, the wife's labor force participation, the wife's income conditional on working, marriage satisfaction, likelihood of divorce, and the division of home production. Within marriage markets, when a randomly chosen woman becomes more likely to earn more than a randomly chosen man, marriage rates decline. In couples where the wife's potential income is likely to exceed the husband's, the wife is less likely to be in the labor force and earns less than her potential if she does work. In couples where the wife earns more than the husband, the wife spends more time on household chores; moreover, those couples are less satisfied with their marriage and are more likely to divorce. These patterns hold both cross-sectionally and within couples over time. JEL Codes: D10, J12, J16.

Specialization Then and Now: Marriage, Children, and the Gender Earnings Gap across Cohorts

“…One set of explanations put forward revolve around social norms that are slow to change and resist economic forces (Fortin 2005;Bertrand 2011;Bertrand, Kamenica, and Pan 2015). Social norms can serve as both push or pull factors.…”

Money vs. Time: Family Income, Maternal Labor Supply, and Child Development

“…We then could use this variation to predict changes in family income and mother's labor supply. Following the approach first developed by Bartik (1991) and used in many previous empirical works (see for example Blanchard and Katz, 1992;Autor and Duggan, 2003;Luttmer, 2005;Aizer, 2010;Notowidigdo, 2011;Bertrand et al, 2015;Diamond, 2016;Charles et al, 2015Charles et al, , 2017, we construct an empirical analogue of the above-mentioned thought experiment by considering the cross-state differences in industrial composition and aggregate growth in the employment level.…”

Top earnings inequality and the gender pay gap: Canada, Sweden, and the United Kingdom

“…As we look to the future and the fact that the current generation of young women attains higher levels of tertiary education than young men, a reversal in the traditional pattern of educational hypergamy (women marrying up) towards hypogamy (Esteve, García-Román, and Permanyer, 2012) might lead to a less traditional division of household responsibilities (Fortin, 2005). Although some recent analyses show little change in the traditional division of housework among dual-earners households with a wife outearner (Bertrand, Kamenica, and Pan, 2015;Sofer and Thibout, 2016). For many women who aim for top jobs, delaying marriage and childbirth (or foregoing it altogether) has become a practical alternative, but it likely has a too low benefit-cost ratio for women aiming to move into the next 9% income group.…”