Gender, Identity, Missions, and Empire: Letters from Christian Teachers in China in the Early 20th and 21st Centuries

Abstract

This article presents the findings of a historically-informed comparative study that juxtaposes the lives of three missionary educators in China in the early 20th century with three Christian educators in China today. Data sources included hundreds of letters from the women written in China to their families and friends over several decades and transcripts of over a dozen interviews. Wenger's social theory of identity formation was used to analyze the data and address the questions of why they went to China, the intended and actual results, and the impact it had on the women and their identity construction. The findings show that although there were major differences across the two centuries, as was expected, there were surprisingly many similarities among the individual teachers, as are noted in the common communities of practice that emerged: "educator," "missionary," "gender advocate," "Chinese advocate," "leader," and "learner."

Early Christian English teachers in Korea: Imperialists or advocates? Exploring the lesser known other truth

“…Stabler-Havener, in like manner, raises concerns about American CETs' disclosure of ''America's most cherished values and ideals'' (Stabler-Havener, 2009: 135-136). Wong (2009Wong ( , 2012Wong ( , 2013Wong ( , 2018 has discussed the dilemmas, delights, and dangers that CETs face as they seek to live out their faith in ways that do not impose their own religious beliefs on their students. Several other scholars in TESOL have debated and discussed the topic, including exchanges in three edited volumes (Wong and Canagarajah, 2009;Wong and Mahboob, 2018;Wong et al, 2013).…”

Revisiting religious higher education in China: comparative analysis of Furen University narratives

“…In recent decades, interest has grown in the history and legacy of Chinese Christian colleges both within and outside mainland China (e.g., Barwick 2004;Graham 1994;Hayhoe 1983;Li 2017;Liu 2009;Ng 2001Ng , 2009Perry and Xu 2020;Rigdon 2009;Ris 2020;Xu 2006;Wong 2012;Zhang 1991). Contemporary PRC scholars have been 1 3 keen to study the interplay between the Christian colleges' Western religious elements and Chinese politics and culture.…”