Immunotherapy using chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)‐engineered lymphocytes has shown impressive results in leukemia. However, for solid tumors such as colorectal cancer (CRC), new preclinical models are needed that allow to test CAR‐mediated cytotoxicity in a tissue‐like environment. Here, we developed a platform to study CAR cell cytotoxicity against 3‐dimensional (3D) patient‐derived colon organoids. Luciferase‐based measurement served as a quantitative read‐out for target cell viability. Additionally, we set up a confocal live imaging protocol to monitor effector cell recruitment and cytolytic activity at a single organoid level. As proof of principle, we demonstrated efficient targeting in diverse organoid models using CAR‐engineered NK‐92 cells directed toward a ubiquitous epithelial antigen (EPCAM). Tumor antigen‐specific cytotoxicity was studied with CAR‐NK‐92 cells targeting organoids expressing EGFRvIII, a neoantigen found in several cancers. Finally, we tested a novel CAR strategy targeting FRIZZLED receptors that show increased expression in a subgroup of CRC tumors. Here, comparative killing assays with normal organoids failed to show tumor‐specific activity. Taken together, we report a sensitive in vitro platform to evaluate CAR efficacy and tumor specificity in a personalized manner.