Biomaterials made by living systems, while very diverse, generally share similar organization: different lineages of cells are precisely patterned within a matrix to create a hierarchically defined structure. This meticulous organization allows for their multifunctional properties, which often exceed those of traditional materials. For these reasons, there is growing interest in creating engineered living materials (ELMs) that will have capabilities similar to those of natural living materials yet with tailored functions. This review aims to highlight technologies still missing from the field of ELMs, which currently prevents more impactful applications. We briefly review the existing literature and identify challenges in designing novel protein-based and non-ribosomally synthesized matrix elements, producing and incorporating biominerals, and improving critical material properties such as lifespan, spatial patterning, and cell-cell communication. We also discuss the interplay between these challenges and the need for the development of new chassis and corresponding genetic toolboxes. By overcoming these obstacles, we come ever closer to unlocking the potential and versatility of biomaterials to create designer ELMs.Protein-based materials (PBMs) are ubiquitous in nature and have often been studied and explored for commercial applications-especially in the biomedical field.