Although C-N bonds are ubiquitous in natural products, pharmaceuticals, and agrochemicals, biocatalysts that forge these bonds with high atom efficiency and enantioselectivity have primarily been limited to a few select enzymes. In particular, the use of ammonia lyases has emerged as a powerful strategy to access C-N bond formation through hydroamination reactions, which has no counterpart in traditional synthetic chemistry. However, the broad utility of ammonia lyases is rather restricted due to their narrow synthetic scope, and the conjugate addition of a matrix of nucleophilic donors to electrophilic acceptors remains a longstanding challenge. Herein, we report the computational redesign of aspartase, a highly specific ammonia lyase, to yield C-N lyases with unprecedented cross-compatibility of nonnative nucleophiles and electrophiles. A wide range of noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs) are afforded with excellent conversion (up to 99%), regioselectivity > 99%, and product enantiomeric excess > 99%, and the process is scalable under industrially relevant protocols (demonstrated in kilogram-scale synthesis). Furthermore, the redesigned enzymes can be facilely integrated in cascade reactions, as we demonstrated the synthesis of β-lactams with different substitution patterns at the N-1 and C-4 positions in a one-pot reaction. This versatile and efficient C-N lyase platform supports the preparation of diverse libraries of ncAAs and their derivatives and will present opportunities in medicinal chemistry and synthetic biology.