Eosinophilic esophagitis (EoE) is a disease that is still not fully understood. Its pathogenesis, while increasingly clarified, still remains highly complex, which means that no curative treatment has been defined for this clinical entity. It is clear that it is a disease of multifactorial etiology, in which both genetics and environmental factors, especially those related to childhood, have considerable weight, and there is an important allergenic factor as well. We present the case of two brothers with EoE. Two male patients aged 20 and 22 years, white, with a personal history of atopy, allergic rhinitis, and dermatitis, consulted the gastroenterologist for dysphagia. Endoscopy and esophageal biopsy showed elements compatible with EoE in both of them. Treatment was conducted with proton pump inhibitor (PPI) monotherapy in one of the brothers, and PPI with oral steroid in the other, both of which led to good results in terms of symptoms. In the first case, histologic evidence of the disease persisted despite the symptomatic resolution; the second did not pursue a follow-up. The biggest questions pertaining to the treatment of this condition are as follows: Is suppression of gastric acidity enough? Should we use steroids? How about a combination of both? Should we adopt new therapies? New studies involving randomized trials should be conducted to address these questions in order to treat each patient individually with an effective and practical approach that is also supported by the literature.