Genomic responses in mouse models poorly mimic human inflammatory diseases

Abstract

A cornerstone of modern biomedical research is the use of mouse models to explore basic pathophysiological mechanisms, evaluate new therapeutic approaches, and make go or no-go decisions to carry new drug candidates forward into clinical trials. Systematic studies evaluating how well murine models mimic human inflammatory diseases are nonexistent. Here, we show that, although acute inflammatory stresses from different etiologies result in highly similar genomic responses in humans, the responses in corresponding mouse models correlate poorly with the human conditions and also, one another. Among genes changed significantly in humans, the murine orthologs are close to random in matching their human counterparts (e.g., R 2 between 0.0 and 0.1). In addition to improvements in the current animal model systems, our study supports higher priority for translational medical research to focus on the more complex human conditions rather than relying on mouse models to study human inflammatory diseases.human disease | translational medicine | inflammation | immune response | injury M urine models have been extensively used in recent decades to identify and test drug candidates for subsequent human trials (1-3). However, few of these human trials have shown success (4-7). The success rate is even worse for those trials in the field of inflammation, a condition present in many human diseases. To date, there have been nearly 150 clinical trials testing candidate agents intended to block the inflammatory response in critically ill patients, and every one of these trials failed (8-11). Despite commentaries that question the merit of an overreliance of animal systems to model human immunology (3,12,13), in the absence of systematic evidence, investigators and public regulators assume that results from animal research reflect human disease. To date, there have been no studies to systematically evaluate, on a molecular basis, how well the murine clinical models mimic human inflammatory diseases in patients.The Inflammation and Host Response to Injury, Large Scale Collaborative Research Program has completed multiple studies on the genomic responses to systemic inflammation in patients and human volunteers as well as murine models (14-18). These datasets include genome-wide expression analysis on white blood cells obtained from serial blood draws in 167 patients up to 28 d after severe blunt trauma (15), 244 patients up to 1 y after burn injury, and 4 healthy humans for 24 h after administration of low-dose bacterial endotoxin (14) and expression analysis on analogous samples from well-established mouse models of trauma, burns, and endotoxemia (16 treated and 16 controls per model) (16-18). In humans, severe inflammatory stress produces a genomic storm affecting all major cellular functions and pathways (15) and therefore, provided sufficient perturbations to allow comparisons between the genes in the human conditions and their orthologs in the murine models.In this article, we report on a systematic comparison of the genomic respo...

Dissociated Oxygen Consumption and Carbon Dioxide Production in the Post–Cardiac Arrest Rat: A Novel Metabolic Phenotype

“…The first is that we studied post‐arrest metabolism in rats. The novel findings reported in this article may not be found in humans 61. We are currently conducting human studies to seek this newly found phenotype in survivors of CA.…”

Perinatal western‐type diet and associated gestational weight gain alter postpartum maternal mood

“…First, the sample size for the human cohort was small, and findings may not be generalizable to all women with PPD/A risk. Second, animal models, although extremely valuable for translational research in many instances, cannot always translate directly to clinical populations (Seok et al., 2013; Takao & Miyakawa, 2015). The model of a Western diet that we utilized enabled us to study the components of high fat and high BCAA separately and in interaction with each other to address our mechanistic hypothesis, but at the cost of including a high carbohydrate or high sugar component, which has also been implicated in a Western‐type diet.…”

Leukotriene B4 indicates lung injury and on-going inflammatory changes after severe trauma in a porcine long-term model

“…In order to improve the clinical prediction of pulmonary complications in trauma patients, both, understanding the underlying pathophysiology and the biology of the repair mechanisms as well as clinically reliable predictive biomarkers are necessary [46]. Moreover, improvement and development of translational trauma models are essential [47]. In the present study, we have evaluated the reliability of the clinically described biomarker LTB4 to indicate the risk for late lung injury and pulmonary complications in the long-term porcine severe polytrauma model.…”