“…Therefore, we cannot directly calculate the magma SiO 2 content either by using fixed
value in mafic or felsic silicate melts, or by using a linear fit through the logarithmic
values for intermediate melt without knowing the melt REE concentrations. Instead, we have compiled apatite REE compositions from mafic to felsic silicate melts with known SiO 2 contents (Alavijeh et al.,
2019; Belousova et al.,
2001; Chu et al.,
2009; Jiang et al.,
2018; Laurent et al.,
2017; Mao et al.,
2016; Van Hoose et al.,
2013; Xing & Wang,
2017; Zhang et al.,
2020). Our results show that the REE (e.g., La, Ce, Sm, Gd, and Dy) concentrations of C‐type, R2‐type, and R1‐type apatite domains generally match well with the apatite from melts with SiO 2 of 45–55 wt.%, 55–65 wt.%, and 65–75 wt.%, respectively (Figure 3f).…”