“…We analyzed benefits resulting from the intensified interaction of producers, processors and other parties in the GI territory to set up the GI protection, but not the post-registration benefits from the very use of the registered GI. We derived relevant benefit categories from GI literature, e.g., vertical and horizontal integration, higher or better accepted quality standards, social learning processes (Sanz-Cañada and Macias-Vázquez, 2005;Giovannucci et al, 2009Giovannucci et al, , 2010Reviron and Chappuis, 2011;Coulet, 2012;Bagal et al, 2013;Barjolle, 2016), but we excluded benefits that would result from the actual use of the GI (e.g., price premiums, rural development benefits). In the action arena analysis and as explanatory variable of efforts, we also included risks linked to possible failures of the collective GI registration process (unsolvable conflicts, lack of information, unclear regulation) ( Barjolle and Sylvander, 2000;Ilbery and Kneafsey, 2000;Giovannucci et al, 2009Giovannucci et al, , 2010Coulet, 2012;Rangnekar and Mukhopadhyay, 2016).…”