Geographical Information Systems, Spatial Analysis and Public Policy: the British Experience

Abstract

Summary Geographic information systems (GIS) have received considerable academic and practitioner attention in the last ten years. It is our view that these tools have been considerably oversold to public sector organisations‐particularly local government‐many of whom have failed to achieve the benefits they expected. In our paper, we attempt to develop a broad definition of GIS and discuss the relationship between GIS and policy analysis, spatial decision support systems, spatial analysis and spatial modelling. We also seek to explore how GIS fits into the management information systems and information architectures of public sector organisations and examine some of the human and organisational tensions which GIS adoption and use have brought about. Where possible, we have used examples of how GIS has been used to inform public development in several areas though these have generally been in academic settings and not in public sector organisations.

Using geographic information systems to compare the density of stores selling tobacco and alcohol: youth making an argument for increased regulation of the tobacco permitting process in Worcester, Massachusetts, USA

“…GIS tools for mapping, analysis and visualisation are increasingly important in urban decision making and policy 21. Participatory community projects use GIS to examine trends, advocate for local issues, insert local knowledge into policy debates and preserve local histories 22–24.…”

The Challenge of Spatial Information Accessibility for Agricultural Policies: Case of Pakistan

“…The implementation of GIS--coupled with a rigorous approach to information management-provides the public sector with a significant opportunity to improve the effectiveness of policy and the efficiency of programmes (Worrall & Bond, 1997). Geographic information is critical to promote economic development, improve our stewardship of natural resources and to protect the environment.…”

Best Practice Principles for Community Indicator Systems and a Case Study Analysis: How Community Indicators Victoria is Creating Impact and Bridging Policy, Practice and Research

“…Spatial presentation and use of Geographic Information System (GIS) data are an alternate source of administrative data and are an additional and important part of the CIV indicator system. GIS is defined as a computer based system for data storage, manipulation, modelling and analysis of spatially or geographically referenced data (Jones, 2007;Worrall & Bond, 1997). It is an extremely useful application for the creation, visualisation and analysis of indicator data.…”