“…Despite such a universality, science has reached no consensus so far about the evolutionary history of voluntary control over the vocal cords in early humans, apart from all other primates (Locke, 1996;Bergman et al, 2019). In line with this discontinuity in evolution, early pragmatics in human infants developing language has shown consistent evidence for gestures predating vocalisations in terms of intentional and conventional uses (Bates et al, 1975;Guidetti et al, 2014;Zlatev and McCune, 2014;Donnellan et al, 2019). Although vocal behaviour has the potential to attain the recipient even in the case of visual inattention, experiencing visual breakdowns might be necessary for signallers to switch from gestures to vocalisations, both in language acquisition (Oller et al, 2016;Bourjade et al, 2023) and in the course of evolution (Falk, 2004;Locke, 2006;Mehr and Krasnow, 2017).…”