Angiomatoid fibrous histiocytoma (AFH) is a relatively rare soft tissue tumour of intermediate malignant potential, occurring most commonly in young adults, with a recognised propensity for local recurrence and occasional metastasis. A case of AFH occurring on the finger of a 60 year old male is described in which the unusual location and age group for this entity raised the original wrong diagnosis of an aneurysmal and cellular fibrous histiocytoma. Further workup demonstrated an EWSR1-CREB1 translocation, confirming the correct diagnosis of AFH. Strong ALK expression using the antibody clone D5F3 was demonstrated in our case on immunohistochemistry, which is in concordance with recent findings of ALK positivity with this antibody in the majority of AFHs.