Giving birth in a Pandemic: Women’s Birth Experiences in England during COVID-19

Abstract

Background: Expectant parents worldwide have experienced changes in the way they give birth as a result of COVID-19, including restrictions relating to access to birthing units and the presence of birthing partners during the birth, and changes to birth plans. This paper reports the experiences of women in England. Methods: Data were obtained from both closed- and open-ended responses collected as part of the national COVID in Context of Pregnancy, Infancy and Parenting (CoCoPIP) Study online survey (n = 477 families) between 15th July 2020 to 29th March 2021. Frequency data are presented alongside the results of a sentiment analysis; the open-ended data was analysed thematically. Results: Two-thirds of expectant women reported giving birth via spontaneous vaginal delivery (SVD) (66.1%) and a third via caesarean section (CS) (32.6%) or other (1.3%). Just under half (49.7%) of the CS were reported to have been elective/planned, with 47.7% being emergencies. A third (37.4%) of participants reported having no changes to their delivery, with a further 25% reporting COVID-related changes, and 37.4% reporting non-COVID related changes (e.g., medical intervention). Experiences of COVID-related changes included limited birthing options and reduced feelings of control; difficulties accessing pain-relief and assistance, and feelings of distress and anxiety. Under half of the respondents reported not knowing whether there could be someone present at the birth (44.8%), with 2.3% of respondents reporting no birthing partner being present due to COVID-related restrictions. Parental experiences of communication and advice provided by the hospital prior to delivery were mixed, with significant stress and anxiety being reported in relation to both the fluctuating guidance and lack of certainty regarding the presence of birthing partners at the birth. The sentiment analysis revealed that participant experiences of giving birth during the pandemic were predominately negative (46.9%) particularly in relation to the first national lockdown, with a smaller proportion of positive (33.2%) and neutral responses (19.9%). Conclusion: Parents reported an overall increase in birthing interventions (e.g., emergency CS), increased uncertainties related to the birth, and poor communication, leading to increased feelings of anxiety and high levels of negative emotions. The implications of these findings are discussed.

Predictors of Postpartum Depression among Italian Women: A Longitudinal Study

“…However, the highest percentage of stable high-risk women found in this study highlights the significant impact of the pandemic on mothers' well-being, which further underlines the importance of offering supportive interventions not only immediately after childbirth, but also throughout the following year. Regarding the childbirth experience, approximately one-third of women reported a very negative experience, emphasizing how the experience of childbirth during the pandemic was negative for many women, as highlighted in a previous study [73].…”

Welcoming new life under lockdown: Exploring the experiences of first‐time mothers who gave birth during the COVID‐19 pandemic

“…Where this is not possible clear communication is vital. Confusion and inconsistencies around birthing partners and preferences were partly down to the fact that each trust within the NHS was allowed to issue their own policy (Aydin et al., 2021 ). This in part suggests the value of more consistent practice across trusts.…”

El enigma del coronavirus – Nuevas subvariantes de subvariantes del SARS-CoV-2 – COVID-19 y embarazo - ¿Existe algún lado bueno de la pandemia?

“…Un documento informa las experiencias de 477 familias en Inglaterra. La proporción de padres que informaron sobre intervenciones en el parto (por ejemplo, una cesárea de emergencia) fue mayor de lo que se había conocido anteriormente, al igual que las incertidumbres relacionadas con el parto y la mala comunicación, lo que provocó un aumento de los sentimientos de ansiedad y altos niveles de emociones negativas (19) . Datos basados en el 99,9% de todos los 2021 registros de nacimiento recibidos y procesados por el Centro Nacional de Estadísticas de Salud de los EE.…”