Sulfonylureas are the most commonly-used second line drug class for treating type 2 diabetes mellitus. While the cardiovascular safety of sulfonylureas has been examined in a number of trials and non-randomized studies, little is known of their specific effects on sudden cardiac arrest and related serious arrhythmic outcomes. This knowledge gap is striking, as persons with diabetes mellitus are at increased risk of sudden cardiac arrest. This review explores sulfonylureas’ influence on the risk of serious arrhythmias, with specific foci on ischemic preconditioning, cardiac excitability, and serious hypoglycemia as putative mechanisms. Elucidating the relationship between individual sulfonylureas and serious arrhythmias is critical, especially as the diabetes epidemic intensifies and sudden cardiac arrest incidence increases in persons with diabetes.