“…First, CDs, like many other nanomaterials, are usually not rigorously purified or otherwise checked for impurities before use. Incidentally, some of the CDs said to reduce silver ions are prepared from materials that are themselves capable of reducing silver ions, such as glucose 19–21 , citric acid 22 , p -phenylenediamine 23–25 , ethylenediamine, 26,27 and antioxidant-rich natural products. 28 It is not impossible that the residual starting material in such a CD preparation is the actual reducing agent.…”