Glyphosate Herbicide Impacts on the Seagrasses Halodule wrightii and Ruppia maritima from a Subtropical Florida Estuary

Abstract

Seagrass meadows are among the most threatened ecosystems on Earth, with losses attributed to increasing coastal populations, degraded water quality and climate change. As coastal communities work to improve water quality, there is increased concern regarding the use of herbicides within the watersheds of these sensitive ecosystems. Glyphosate is the most widely used herbicide on Earth because it is non-selective and lethal to most plants. Also, the targeted amino acid synthesis pathway of glyphosate is not carried out by vertebrates, and it is generally considered one of the safer but effective herbicides on the market. At least partially due to its cost-effectiveness compared to other techniques, including mechanical harvesting, glyphosate use in the aquatic environment has increased in coastal areas to manage aquatic weeds, maintain navigable waterways and mitigate upland flooding. This has prompted concerns regarding potential ecosystem-level impacts. To test the acute toxicity of glyphosate to seagrasses, mesocosm experiments exposed Ruppia maritima and Halodule wrightii to 1 ppm, 100 ppm and 1000 ppm of glyphosate (as glyphosate acid). No significant decrease in leaf chlorophyll a (Chl a) was identified for either species at 1 ppm versus a control; however, significant decreases were observed at higher concentrations. In all except 1000 ppm mesocosms, water column Chl a increased, with a 7-fold increase at 100 ppm. These data demonstrate that at very high glyphosate concentrations, both acute toxicity and light limitation from enhanced algal biomass may have adverse impacts on seagrasses. Despite these observations, no significant adverse impacts attributed to acute toxicity were observed at 1 ppm, which is >1000 times higher than concentrations measured in the Indian River Lagoon system. Overall, herbicide use and associated decaying biomass contribute nutrients to these systems, in contrast to the removal of nutrients when mechanical harvesting is used. Based on our data and calculations, when used at recommended application rates, contributions to eutrophication, degraded water quality and harmful algal blooms were more likely to impact seagrasses than acute toxicity of glyphosate.