Governance in health workforce: how do we improve on the concept? A network-based, stakeholder-driven approach

Abstract

Background Health workforce governance has been proposed as key to improving health services delivery, yet few studies have examined the conceptualisation of health workforce governance in detail and exploration in literature remains limited. Methods A literature review using PubMed, Google Scholar and grey literature search was conducted to map out the current conceptualisation of health workforce governance. We identified all published literature relating to governance in health workforce since 2000 and analysed them on two fronts: the broad definition of governance, and the operationalisation of broad definition into key dimensions of governance. Results Existing literature adopts governance concepts established in health literature and does not adapt understanding to the health workforce context. Definitions are largely quoted from health literature whilst dimensions are focused around the sub-functions of governance which emphasise operationalising governance practices over further conceptualisation. Two sub-functions are identified as essential to the governance process: stakeholder participation and strategic direction. Conclusions Although governance in health systems has gained increasing attention, governance in health workforce remains poorly conceptualised in literature. We propose an improved conceptualisation in the form of a stakeholder-driven network governance model with the national government as a strong steward against vested stakeholder interests. Further research is needed to explore and develop on the conceptual thinking behind health workforce governance.

Public health consequences after ten years of the Syrian crisis: a literature review

“…74% were exposed to verbal violence, while 19% were exposed to physical violence. There was a significant positive correlation between verbal and physical violence and each item of depression and stress, as well as a significant negative correlation between subjective sleep quality and subjective health [ 74 ].…”

Towards an Integrated Healthcare System: Evolutionary Game Analysis on Competition and Cooperation Between Urban and Rural Medical Institutions in China

“…Association between medical and health institutions. In the process of healthcare governance and partnership, Lim and Lin ( 9 ), a Scholar from Hong Kong, China, pointed out that the government should play a key role in coordinating the concerns and priorities of relevant parties to achieve health goals. In terms of specific collaboration content, Lemetti et al ( 10 ) revealed the importance of collaboration between the hospital and primary health care providers for continuity of care for elderly patients.…”

Healthcare workers’ perceptions and medically approved COVID-19 infection risk: understanding the mental health dimension of the pandemic. A German hospital case study

“…These threats may be preventable, at least to some degree, through innovation in the governance of pandemic preparedness and health workforce protection (10,36,52), that take the 'dual pandemic' ( 9) dimension of COVID-19 and the 'human face' of the health workforce (44) more systematically into account.…”

“…We use Hannover Medical School (50) as an explorative case study, a large university hospital (academic medical centre) in Lower Saxony, a state in the Western part of Germany. Theoretically, our analysis is informed by multi-level health workforce governance (51,52). More specifically, our approach places the perceptions of HCWs in the context of institutional conditions, taking system, sector and organisational levels into account (12).…”