Rio Celeste ("Sky-Blue River") is a river located in the Tenorio National Park (Costa Rica) that has become an important hotspot for eco-tourism due to its striking sky-blue color. A previous study suggested that this color is not caused by dissolved chemical species, but by precipitation of light-scattering aluminosilicate particles at the mixing point of two colorless streams, the acidic Quebrada Agria and the neutral Rio Buenavista. We now present microbiological information on Rio Celeste and its two tributaries, as well as a more detailed characterization of the particles that occur at the mixing point. Our results overturn the previous belief that the light scattering particles are formed by the aggregation of smaller particles coming from Rio Buenavista, and rather point to chemical formation of hydroxyaluminosilicate colloids with Quebrada Agria as the main contributor to the phenomenon, with Rio Buenavista acting as a secondary source of silica to the reaction. We also show how the sky-blue color of Rio Celeste arises from the tight interaction between chemical and biological processes. Sulfur-oxidizing bacteria generate an acidic environment in Quebrada Agria, which in turn cause dissolution and mobilization of aluminum and other metals, while in Rio Buenavista the growth of diatoms transforms dissolved silicon into colloidal biogenic forms. The local interaction between these two well-known biological activities gives rise to the unique Rio Celeste phenomenon, in what constitutes a textbook example of emergent behavior in environmental microbiology.