This work focuses on the performance and stability of selected commercial carbon electrode materials before and after heat-treatment in an operating all-vanadium redox flow battery (VRB). Heat treatment results in improved cell performance for all tested materials, with SGL 39 AA carbon papers and SIGRACELL GFD4.6 EA carbon felt showing the best performance. Further investigation of these two materials by in situ reference electrode measurements reveal improvements after heat-treatment that originate mainly from the negative electrode or V 2+ /V 3+ side of the cell. Upon extended cycling, carbon felt is found to be stable. Carbon papers however, show significant performance losses originating from the negative electrode side. The potential limit during charging and the exposure to very negative potentials appears to be a critical issue at the negative electrode in the VRB. Analysis of both materials after cycling by scanning electron microscopy, Raman spectroscopy and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy reveal significant differences in their surface chemistry, structure and morphology. These differences give valuable insights into the behavior and degradation of different carbon materials used in VRBs. Redox flow batteries (RFBs) are a promising technology for efficient energy storage and grid stabilization.1,2 The all-vanadium redox flow battery (VRB), which uses vanadium ions in different oxidation states at the positive and negative electrodes, is the most advanced RFB to date.3 The electrodes are a crucial component of the VRB, as they provide the surface on which the respective electrochemical reactions occur. Thus, catalytic activity, wettability and mass transport properties of the electrodes strongly affect VRB performance. Ideal electrodes for the VRB should provide both: long term durability and stable catalytic activity. Various materials have been considered as electrodes for the use in VRBs including non-carbon based dimensionally stable anode electrodes and carbon based electrodes such as carbon felt, carbon paper, carbon nanotubes, carbon nanofibers or graphene oxides. 4 To enhance electrochemical activity and wettability of carbon based materials in VRBs, different surface modification methods have been used. Carbon electrodes have been coated with metals such as iridium, 5 doped with nitrogen 6 or decorated with nanomaterials such as graphene-nanowalls 7 or graphite carbon nanotubes. Most of these surface treatment approaches introduce functional groups, commonly oxygen onto the carbon electrode surface. This leads to increased wettability and redox activity, which is generally attributed to the increased concentration of surface-active oxygen functional groups.11 Among the various surface modifications, heattreatment is still regarded as the most common and facile approach to incorporate oxygen groups onto the surface of carbon materials. 4 In an effort to better understand the role of oxygen functional groups on electrode performance, Fink et al. studied pristine and heat-treated Rayon (a regene...