Gravitational Dispersion Forces and Gravity Quantization

Abstract

The parallel development of the theories of electrodynamical and gravitational dispersion forces reveals important differences. The former arose earlier than the formulation of quantum electrodynamics so that expressions for the unretarded, van der Waals forces were obtained by treating the field as classical. Even after the derivation of quantum electrodynamics, semiclassical considerations continued to play a critical role in the interpretation of the full results, including in the retarded regime. On the other hand, recent predictions about the existence of gravitational dispersion forces were obtained without any consideration that the gravitational field might be fundamentally classical. This is an interesting contrast, as several semiclassical theories of electrodynamical dispersion forces exist although the electromagnetic field is well known to be quantized, whereas no semiclassical theory of gravitational dispersion forces was ever developed although a full quantum theory of gravity is lacking. In the first part of this paper, we explore this evolutionary process from a historical point of view, stressing that the existence of a Casimir effect is insufficient to demonstrate that a field is quantized. In the second part of the paper, we show that the recently published results about gravitational dispersion forces can be obtained without quantizing the gravitational field. This is done first in the unretarded regime by means of Margenau’s treatment of multipole dispersion forces, also obtaining mixed potentials. These results are extended to the retarded regime by generalizing to the gravitational field the approach originally proposed by McLachlan. The paper closes with a discussion of experimental challenges and philosophical implications connected to gravitational dispersion forces.

Special Issue: “Symmetries in Quantum Mechanics”

“…Prof. Pinto gives a careful review in "Gravitational Dispersion Forces and Gravity Quantization" [11] of the history of electrodynamic dispersion forces, detailing the classical and semi-classical explanations and the later quantum developments, and contrasts this development to the purely quantum discussions of gravitational dispersion forces, which, however, can also be considered within a semi-classical framework. He sheds light on the common assumption that the gravitational field is necessarily a quantized field, and suggests that data do not support the conclusion that the gravitational field must be quantized.…”