A key benefit of botanically diverse landscapes is their ability to attract and support wildlife. Nature relatedness, a term that describes the affective, cognitive, and experiential aspect of human-nature relations, promotes positive well-being and happiness. Wildlife is a broad term which can include insects, reptiles, birds, and mammals. Because markets are typically heterogeneous, consumers are likely to respond differently to landscapes that are wildlife-friendly. The present study used an online survey to explore U.S. consumer preferences for 10 different types of wildlife in landscapes. Participants wanted landscapes that attracted songbirds, butterflies, pollinators, and bees. In general, participants were neutral about attracting gamebirds, deer, and chipmunks. However, they wanted to deter insects, bats, and snakes. Greater native plant knowledge and higher nature relatedness ratings improved the probability of participants wanting to attract all 10 types of wildlife. Demographics impacted preferences with older participants wanting to attract songbirds, butterflies, bees, and pollinators but deter all other types of wildlife. On average, women wanted to attract butterflies but deter game birds, deer, chipmunks, insects, bats, and snakes. Rural residents were more interested in attracting all types of wildlife. People with children wanted to attract gamebirds, deer, and chipmunks to their landscapes.