Inorganic N fertilizers are important to continuous systems of winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L. em Thell.) in the U.S. southern Great Plains (SGP). Costs have increased in recent years and resulted in producers considering summer‐grown legumes as green N sources. This study (2008–2012) defined effects of lablab [Lablab purpureus (L.) Sweet ‘Rio Verde’] cover crops on subsequent forage production by wheat under conventional and no‐till management, compared to soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr. ‘Laredo’], two inorganic fertilizer rates (40; 80 kg N ha−1yr−1), and unfertilized controls. Inoculated legume seeds were sown annually after wheat harvest, grown during June to August, and terminated in early‐September. Wheat was sown late‐September and samples collected at four growth stages through maturity. Wheat forage (kg ha−1), N concentration (g kg−1) and N accumulated (kg N ha−1) in forage were analyzed to define treatment, tillage, growth stage, and year effects. Precipitation was 53 to 92% of long‐term average (LTA) for the wheat growing (October‐May) period (1977–2012; 688 mm). Treatment x year interaction was significant (P < 0.01) for biomass, N concentration, and N accumulated in forage. Treatment effects on forage production varied among years; response to legume treatments were ≤ control. Response of N concentration and N accumulated in forage under legume treatments were largely ≤ control; responses to all treatments declined with length of study. Neither legume was an effective N source for forage production by continuous wheat systems in the SGP.