Growth patterns of normo‐nourished Afghan, Haitian and Congolese children aged 6–59 months: A comparative study

Abstract

Objectives International growth charts have been used in the past decades to identify atypical growth and diagnose the nutritional status of individuals. The aim of this study was to construct and compare growth patterns of normo‐nourished children between 6–59 months from Afghanistan, Haiti, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, to assess if it would be worth developing growth charts at a national level. Methods We used an international sample of 46 466 subjects (53.7% female; 46.3% male) from the aforementioned regions. To create the growth charts, we used different statistical methodologies: the Lambda‐Mu‐Sigma (LMS), LMSP, and LMST models, and regression models based on fractional polynomials. The LMSP models were the ones that fitted our data best and were therefore the ones used to make comparisons between countries using percentiles (3rd, 50th, and 97th). Results We found that Haitian children were both, taller and heavier than their Afghan and Congolese equals of the same ages. Moreover, differences were bigger in the highest percentiles (i.e., 97th percentile). These differences might be the result of the influence that genetics and diverse social and environmental contexts have on growth rates. Conclusions Using the same international reference standards for all populations could result in the overestimation or underestimation of the proportion of malnourished children. In light of our results, we recommend the future development of national and regional growth charts to provide health workers with more precise tools to evaluate the nutritional status in the child population.

Comparison of waist circumference and waist‐to‐height ratio as predictors of clustering of cardiovascular risk factors among middle‐aged people in rural Khanh Hoa, Vietnam

“…As expected, our findings suggest that the recommended Asian cut-off, particularly for men, was not appropriate in rural Khanh Hoa because of the shorter stature (approximately 162 cm for men); shorter people tend to have smaller WC due to smaller body size, irrespective of their cardiometabolic risk, and they might be misclassified as not having abdominal obesity. Therefore, our findings suggest that a certain proportion of our study participants might have been misclassified if the current Asian cut-off of 90 cm for WC had been applied, emphasizing the need for population-specific cut-off points, as exemplified by several previous studies which identified population-specific cut-offs for anthropometric metrics among individuals of various age groups (de Wilde et al, 2020;Hruschka, 2021;Martín-Turrero et al, 2022).…”

Composite indexes of anthropometric failure in children under 5 years of age in Argentina: Comparative analysis among regions: 2019–2020

“…The population differences were practically nil and therefore these values could be applied universally (WHO, 2006b). Subsequent studies, in which the authors of the present study participated and which have been published in this same journal (Lescure et al, 2023;Martín-Turrero et al, 2022) have shown that growth patterns of healthy children may vary among populations of different origins, so that the WHO standards may moderately overestimate or underestimate the rates of child malnutrition in some populations.…”

Differences in wasting assessment through Middle‐Upper Arm Circumference (MUAC) adjusted by sex, age and geographic origin for children aged 6–59 months: New reference based on anthropometric surveys from 22 low‐and‐middle‐income countries

“…In addition, the degree of disagreement in the diagnosis seems to be affected by population‐type factors such as body shape and proportionality (Laillou et al, 2014). Furthermore, the diagnostic differences are not exclusive to the WHZ and MUAC indicators, and comparative studies have shown that there are differences in growth patterns at the international level (Martín‐Turrero et al, 2021).…”