Information about photosynthesis−irradiance (P−I) relationships is crucial in many primary production studies. This is frequently obtained using incubation experiments, which may not simulate in situ conditions where algae are adjusting their photosynthetic systems to permanent light variations. There has been increasing interest in pulse-amplitude-modulated (PAM) chlorophyll fluorometry-which measures instantaneous photosynthetic response -particularly in the use of rapid light curves (RLCs) to minimize the confounding effects of light acclimation encountered with traditional 'steady-state' light curves (SSLC). However, there is still a lack of information about how oxygen SSLC curves and estimations from fluorescence P−I curves are related. The present study addresses some of these topics, using Laminaria hyperborea. The objectives of this study were to (1) determine the effect of light sequence (increasing or decreasing) in the estimation of P−I parameters, (2) characterize the daily patterns of P−I curve parameters, (3) compare oxygen and fluorescence P−I parameters and (4) evaluate the possibility of converting fluorescence P−I parameters into oxygen production measurements. Results showed that light sequence had no significant effect on P−I parameters (fluorescence and oxygen) and that P−I curves exhibited considerable differences over the day (F-ratio analysis). Fluorescence SSLCs and RLCs were good oxygen production predictors only at sub-saturating irradiances, when significant linear relationships were obtained with results from oxygen incubations. Thus care should be taken when interpreting PAM fluorescence gross production estimations from higher light intensities.
KEY WORDS: Photosynthesis−irradiance relationship · Oxygen incubations · Steady-state light curves · Rapid light curvesResale or republication not permitted without written consent of the publisher Aquat Biol 19: 29-44, 2013 cesses. This dynamic nature may preclude the usage of static P−I relationships, i.e. equations with fixed parameters; instead, these 'parameters' may have to be treated as variables.The P−I relationship of macroalgae is frequently studied using incubation experiments, where algae are kept under different light levels for a period long enough to observe significant changes in dissolved oxygen within the incubation vessels, as a result of photosynthesis and respiration. Physiologically 'oriented' experiments may use small pieces of macroalgae (e.g. Franklin & Badger 2001), allowing more experimental control of light-intensity conditions and, possibly, reducing error variance among replicates if pieces of similar shape, size and cut from the same part of the thallus are used. These experiments provide useful physiological information due to high control of experimental conditions. However, if the main interest is simulating in situ photosynthesis, within the scope of an ecologically 'oriented' study, it is probably more appropriate to use whole organisms in experiments with proper replication, to account for ...