H-Index Predicts Academic Rank Among Full-time Academic Orthopaedic Trauma Surgeons Affiliated with Fellowship Programs

Abstract

Objectives: The purpose was to investigate the association between Hirsch index (H-index) and academic rank among orthopaedic trauma surgeons affiliated with Orthopaedic Trauma Association (OTA) and Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) fellowship programs with academic appointments. Additional variables investigated included total number of publications and training program affiliation. Design: Database review. Participants: Orthopaedic trauma surgery faculty members at OTA and ACGME orthopaedic trauma surgery fellowship. Main outcome measurement: H-index, total number of publications, academic rank, and fellowship training pedigree. Results: The H-indices of 273 orthopaedic traumatologists from 57 fellowship programs were organized and calculated. There are strong correlations among total number of publications, citations, and H-index. Overall, there is a strong association with number of publications, number of citations, and H-index with higher academic rank. Overall, H-index was a stronger predictor of academic rank than total number of publications and citations. Appointment to the same program as an individual’s fellowship training program and orthopaedic subspeciality fellowship outside of traumatology were not associated with academic rank. Level of Evidence: IV, case series Key words: trauma, fellowship, academic rank, H-index

Gender Disparities Among Academic Vitreoretinal Specialists in the United States With Regard to Scholarly Impact and Academic Rank

“…While the h-index is used worldwide for measuring a physician’s publication productivity, it has limitations and has received criticism from several corners, which needs to be considered. It is important to note that a single metric can only provide a rough approximation of an individual’s overall profile [ 33 , 36 ]. Additionally, if a full professor has not published much over many years, their h-index may still remain the same as that of a younger professor who has published a few highly cited articles.…”

Orthopaedic Shoulder and Elbow Fellowship Directors in the United States Have Substantial Research Output but Lack Diversity

“…Of note, an investigation of orthopaedic trauma surgeons performed by Simson et al. 11 found that a strong correlation exists between the total number of publications, citations, and H-index and a higher academic rank. In addition, few studies highlight sex and racial disparities present in orthopaedic surgery, along with the potential impacts such disparities have on the field.…”