Hard to get: The scarcity of women and the competition for high-income men in urban China

Abstract

Reports of the difficulties of elite women in finding suitable mates have been increasing despite the growing availability and value of men in China. We rationalize this "leftover women" phenomenon within the directed/competitive search framework, which uniquely allows for equilibrium crowding out. Within this framework, we show that the leftover women phenomenon can be the result of women's aversion to men who have a lower income than themselves (hereafter, ALM) and the long-predicted complementarity between women's non-market traits (in particular, beauty) and male earnings. For high-income (h-)women, even when high-income (H-)men are more plentiful and richer, the direct effect of the greater number of desirable men can be overwhelmed by the indirect effect of competitive 'entry' by low-income (l-)women, particularly, the beautiful. We test for these competitive search effects using online dating field experimental, Census, and household survey data. Consistent with the competitive entry of lwomen, when sex ratio and H-men's income increase, the search intensity of beautiful l-women for H-men increases. In response to this competitive entry, plain h-women, who are constrained by their ALM to search predominantly for H-men, also increase the search intensity. However, only their marriage probability decreases. Our evidence is consistent with intra-female competitive search for spouses who can cover the labor market opportunity cost of marriage and childbirth, which increases with a woman's income.

Lowering Standards to Wed? Spouse Quality, Marriage, and Labor Market Responses to the Gender Wage Gap

“…This paper relates to several literatures. First, it adds to the set of studies on the causal determinants of spouse quality, which has thus far focused exclusively on the role of the balance of sexes in the market (Charles & Luoh, 2010;Angrist, 2002;Abramitzky, Delavande, & Vasconcelos, 2011;Ong, Yang, & Zhang, 2020) or individual education (McCrary & Royer, 2011;Geruso & Royer, 2018). I show that labor market opportunities have a significant impact on partner choice and argue that selection out of less desirable marriages is an important channel for this effect.…”

The College Admissions Contribution to the Labor Market Beauty Premium

“…Raters were asked to choose the more physically attractive within each pair. Instead of asking raters for a numerical rating within a certain range of numbers, as is standard in the field (Hamermesh and Biddle 1994), we followed the methodology in Ong, Yang, and Zhang (2020) asked raters to decide only which photo of a pair is better-looking. Such a judgment may be easier and more precise than assigning a number to indicate how good-looking someone is according to a subjective numerical scale (Negahban, Oh, and Shah 2012).…”

Too Many Men, Too Short Lives: The Effect of the Male-Biased Sex Ratio on Mortality

“…1 Ong et al (2019) show that there is a "left-over women" phenomenon in Mainland China, despite the increasing number of men in the marriage market in the past several decades due to elite women's inclination to marry richer men. If this holds true for Taiwan, the existence of "left-over women" would further reduce the We define county sex ratios at ages 30 and 35, respectively, as the ratios of men to women who were aged 25-34 and 30-39 and resided in the county in the year when each individual reached ages 30 and 35.…”