Hard Work and Fun: Collective Online Interaction in a Case of Photo Fraud

Abstract

Online platforms devoted to investigating criminal cases or mysteries are often seen as reaching outwards to identify suspects, promote punishment, and try to solve cases. Simultaneously, internal interactions between posters motivate them to contribute, even to outdo one another, and so a team spirit emerges. This article analyzes a lengthy thread on a Swedish Internet discussion forum, Flashback, in which a wildlife photographer was exposed for manipulating photographs. We explore how the online interaction is characterized by both competition and collaboration, as well as hard work and displayed expertise, and is framed in terms of the morally right and an underdog perspective. The posters' activities are largely directed at the photographer's moral wrongdoing and take the form of an internal process between the participants, where work and play merge. We analyzed the case with the help of Randall Collins' interaction rituals, Erving Goffman's frames, and the concept of playbour.

Picking the Goodies When Sleuthing Online

“…Imaginatively, we might even talk about a third environment-the digitally represented scene and its context-to which an online discussion can be devoted. An illuminating case is the field of online sleuthing, which focuses on representing, dramatizing, and disentangling offline criminal activities and thereby-in and through interactional processes-digitally immersing people into often quite intense detective work (Burcar Alm et al, 2023). Here, the Internet and its online communities do not function as settings for criminal projects or forms of victimization, but as settings of reality constructions tied to social control.…”