Quantum atmosphere effective radii for the emission of spin-0, 1/2, 1, and 2 massless fields from Schwarzschild, Tangherlini, non-commutative geometry inspired, and polymeric black holes are calculated. The power observed from the black hole at spatial infinity taking greybody factors into account is compared to an equal-power black-body radiator of the same temperature but different effective radius. A large range of different radii are obtained for different spin fields and black holes. The equal-power black-body effective radius is not, in general, a good proxy for the location of the quantum atmosphere.