Head acceleration measurement techniques: Reliability of angular rate sensor data in helmeted impact testing

Abstract

This study sought to evaluate the suitability of angular rate sensors for quantifying angular acceleration in helmeted headform impacts. A helmeted Hybrid III headform, instrumented with a 3-2-2-2 nine accelerometer array and angular rate sensors, was impacted (n = 90) at six locations and three velocities (3.1, 4.9, and 6.4 m/s). Data were low-pass filtered using Butterworth four-pole phaseless digital filters which conform to the specifications described in the Society of Automotive Engineers J211 standard on instrumentation for impact tests. Nine accelerometer array data were filtered using channel frequency class 180, which corresponds to a −3 db cutoff frequency of 300 Hz. Angular rate sensor data were filtered using channel frequency class values ranging from 5 to 1000 Hz in increments of 5 Hz, which correspond to −3 db cutoff frequencies of 8 to 1650 Hz. Root-mean-square differences in peak angular acceleration between the two instrumentation schemes were assessed for each channel frequency class value. Filtering angular rate sensor data with channel frequency class values between 120 and 205 all produced mean differences within ±5%. The minimum root-mean-square difference of 297 rad/s2 was found when the angular rate sensor data were filtered using channel frequency class 175. This filter specification resulted in a mean difference of 28 ± 297 rad/s2 (1.8% ± 8.6%). Condition-specific differences (α=0.05) were observed for 11 of 18 test conditions. A total of 4 of those 11 conditions were within ±5%, and 10 were within ±10%. Furthermore, the nine accelerometer array and angular rate sensor methods demonstrated similar levels of repeatability. These data suggest that angular rate sensor may be an appropriate alternative to the nine accelerometer array for measuring angular head acceleration in helmeted head impact tests with impactor velocities of 3.1–6.4 m/s and impact durations of approximately 10 ms.

Head Impact Exposure and Biomechanics in University Varsity Women’s Soccer

“… 41 After transformation, a low-pass Butterworth filter at 300 and 258 Hz cutoff was used for accelerometer and gyroscope data, respectively. 9 , 16 , 50 Peak values of resultant linear acceleration, angular velocity and acceleration were calculated for each video-verified mouthpiece event. In addition to peak angular velocity, we also calculated the peak change in angular velocity for each impact, since soccer heading impacts mostly have non-zero initial angular velocities.…”

Development and Evaluation of a Test Method for Assessing the Performance of American Football Helmets

“…These sensor packages were previously shown to provide statistically similar results. 9 Post-impact travel of the ram was limited to 170 ± 5 mm and laboratory temperature was kept constant at 22 ± 2°C.…”

Relating on-field youth football head impacts to pneumatic ram laboratory testing procedures

“…Linear acceleration data was filtered according to SAE J211 standards (CFC 1000), while angular rate data was filtered at a frequency of 255 Hz. 28 For each test, peak linear resultant head acceleration, peak rotational resultant head acceleration, and SI were computed. It should be noted that the NOCSAE standard does stipulate the use of a nine accelerometer array to compute linear and rotational impact kinematics with all data filtered at a frequency of 300 Hz (CFC 180).…”