Health System Challenges in Organizing Quality Diabetes Care for Urban Poor in South India

Abstract

BackgroundWeak health systems in low- and middle-income countries are recognized as the major constraint in responding to the rising burden of chronic conditions. Despite recognition by global actors for the need for research on health systems, little attention has been given to the role played by local health systems. We aim to analyze a mixed local health system to identify the main challenges in delivering quality care for diabetes mellitus type 2.MethodsWe used the health system dynamics framework to analyze a health system in KG Halli, a poor urban neighborhood in South India. We conducted semi-structured interviews with healthcare providers located in and around the neighborhood who provide care to diabetes patients: three specialist and 13 non-specialist doctors, two pharmacists, and one laboratory technician. Observations at the health facilities were recorded in a field diary. Data were analyzed through thematic analysis.ResultThere is a lack of functional referral systems and a considerable overlap in provision of outpatient care for diabetes across the different levels of healthcare services in KG Halli. Inadequate use of patients’ medical records and lack of standard treatment protocols affect clinical decision-making. The poor regulation of the private sector, poor systemic coordination across healthcare providers and healthcare delivery platforms, widespread practice of bribery and absence of formal grievance redress platforms affect effective leadership and governance. There appears to be a trust deficit among patients and healthcare providers. The private sector, with a majority of healthcare providers lacking adequate training, operates to maximize profit, and healthcare for the poor is at best seen as charity.ConclusionsSystemic impediments in local health systems hinder the delivery of quality diabetes care to the urban poor. There is an urgent need to address these weaknesses in order to improve care for diabetes and other chronic conditions.

Barriers to Point-of-Care Testing in India: Results from Qualitative Research across Different Settings, Users and Major Diseases

“…Social relations can prolong disease detection, disrupt test and treat cycles and reduce treatment adherence through weak referral system and because the onus is on patients to seek care. Social relations can also reduce confidence in each other’s quality of diagnostic work and integrity [ 56 ] or confidence in care offered at public and private clinics, for instance due to the lack of coordination in the public sector and kick-backs in the private sector.…”

“…Attempts have also been made to cut delays and increase coordination among providers in diagnosing malaria by placing rapid tests at drug shops in Uganda [ 58 ]. The unregulated nature of the Indian private healthcare and diagnostic sector contributes to the lack of coordination among providers, as is widely recognized in literature on the Indian health system [ 41 , 43 , 56 ]. Our results also show that local forms of coordination among private doctors and labs, motivated by attempts to maintain client relationships, ensure POC continuums to some extent.…”

Improving Access to Medicines for Non-Communicable Diseases in Rural Primary Care: Results from a Cluster Randomised Trial in a District in South India

“…The NCD programme aims to integrate health promotion, early diagnosis, treatment and referral, and further facilitate partnerships with the private sector in order to address rising burden of NCDs (15). Various health system readiness issues have been posited as possible reasons for poor availability and utilisation of NCD care at PHCs (16)(17)(18)(19)(20)(21).…”

Private Diabetes Care Delivery in Iran, is it Cost-Effective?

“…Thus, health care providers could play a critical role in improving the quality of care delivered to diabetic patients (6). Several studies have identi ed signi cant gaps between private and public sectors in their costs and quality of care (8)(9)(10)(11). This study aimed to analyze the costs and outcomes of diabetes care in public and private diabetes centers in Iran, which may also have lessons for other developing countries.…”