Health systems integration: state of the evidence

Abstract

IntroductionIntegrated health systems are considered a solution to the challenge of maintaining the accessibility and integrity of healthcare in numerous jurisdictions worldwide. However, decision makers in a Canadian health region indicated they were challenged to find evidence-based information to assist with the planning and implementation of integrated healthcare systems.MethodsA systematic literature review of peer-reviewed literature from health sciences and business databases, and targeted grey literature sources.ResultsDespite the large number of articles discussing integration, significant gaps in the research literature exist. There was a lack of high quality, empirical studies providing evidence on how health systems can improve service delivery and population health. No universal definition or concept of integration was found and multiple integration models from both the healthcare and business literature were proposed in the literature. The review also revealed a lack of standardized, validated tools that have been systematically used to evaluate integration outcomes. This makes measuring and comparing the impact of integration on system, provider and patient level challenging.Discussion and conclusionHealthcare is likely too complex for a one-size-fits-all integration solution. It is important for decision makers and planners to choose a set of complementary models, structures and processes to create an integrated health system that fits the needs of the population across the continuum of care. However, in order to have evidence available, decision makers and planners should include evaluation for accountability purposes and to ensure a better understanding of the effectiveness and impact of health systems integration.

Integration of Mental and Physical Health Services: Lessons

“…Integrated healthcare, or 'integrated care', has been defined in 175 ways [6]. It is worth looking at what the WHO has to say about this:…”

Scoping of models to support population-based regional health planning and management: comparison with the regional operating model in Victoria, Australia

“…1,2 It has been recognised that systems are not well integrated, there is duplication and waste throughout the service platforms and ways are needed to reverse these trends. [3][4][5] This has led them to focus on better service integration and more targeted healthcare to those who most need it. Policy makers increasingly realise that if the health sector better meets the needs of the population, they may achieve better health outcomes and increase cost-effectiveness.…”

Gestão do cuidado integral: estudo de caso em região de saúde da Bahia, Brasil

“…Extensa revisão sobre integração de sistemas de saúde 27 aponta insuficiência de estudos empíricos que forneçam evidências para tomada de decisão e falta de ferramentas validadas e padronizadas para avaliação dos resultados, o que torna a tarefa de medir e comparar o impacto da integração no nível das práticas, serviços e sistema um grande desafio para gestores e pesquisadores. Nessa perspectiva, preencher parte destas lacunas é uma das intenções desta pesquisa.…”