Healthcare leadership’s diversity paradox

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this research study was to obtain healthcare executives' perspectives on diversity in executive healthcare leadership. The study focused on identifying perspectives about diversity and its potential impact on the access of healthcare services by people of color. The study also identified perspectives about factors that influence the attainment of executive healthcare roles by people of color. Design/methodology/approach A convenience sample of healthcare executives was obtained. The executives identified themselves as belonging to one of two subgroups, White healthcare executives or executives of color. Participants were interviewed telephonically in a semi-structured format. The interviews were transcribed and entered into a qualitative software application. The data were codified and important themes were identified. Findings The majority of the study participants perceive that diversity of the executive healthcare leadership team is important. There were differences in perspective among the subgroups as it relates to solutions to improve access to healthcare by people of color. There were also differences in perspective among the subgroups, as it relates to explaining the underrepresentation of people of color in executive healthcare leadership roles. Research limitations/implications This research effort benefited from the subject matter expertise of 24 healthcare executives from two states. Expansion of the number of survey participants and broadening the geographical spread of where participants were located may have yielded more convergence and/or more divergence in perspectives about key topics. Practical implications The findings from this research study serve to add to the existing body of literature on diversity in executive healthcare leadership. The findings expand on the importance of key elements in contemporary literature such as diversity, cultural competency and perspectives about the need for representation of people of color in leadership roles that guide healthcare policy and access. This study connects contemporary literature to perspectives of executives in the field and offers practical solutions to improving the representation of people of color in executive healthcare leadership roles. Social implications The recommendations offered as a result of this research effort serve to create awareness of the challenges that people of color face in career attainment. Although the process of increasing the representation of people of color in executive healthcare leadership will be a complex task that will involve a number of players over the course of several years, this study serves to provide a practical roadmap with actionable tactics that can be deployed. Originality/value This paper is an extension of the work that was done by the author during the course of completing the program requirements for the author's doctoral program. The findings were previously discussed in the author's dissertation. The value of these findings is significant because they validate some of t...

Diversity in Academic Otolaryngology: An Update and Recommendations for Moving From Words to Action

“…Our secondary objective was to characterize the relationship between the presence of these initiatives and program-specific gender diversity. We found, as seen in other studies, 23-29 that women are underrepresented in both OHNS and general surgery residency programs and in leadership positions.…”

“…Otolaryngology consistently ranks near the bottom in gender and ethnic diversity compared to other subspecialties. 19,20 Despite modest gains in recent years, 19 women and underrepresented minorities (URMs) still experience lack of advancement into leadership positions in medicine at large, 21-26 and in otolaryngology specifically. 27-29…”

Cultural Diversity in Top Management Teams – Review and Agenda for Future Research

“…Research has also examined factors that shape the climate of organizational diversity, including firm-level diversity programs and initiatives and the internationalization level of other power groups in the organization that can potentially reduce the costs of TMTs' increased cultural diversity. Some studies argue that perceptions of racial diversity in the executive suite differ significantly among organizational subgroups (Silver 2017). Against this backdrop, firm-level diversity programs directed at raising the awareness of diversity issues among multiple groups within an organizaiton are key for the increase the level of perceived racial diversity in the executive suite (Allen, Dawson, Wheatley, & White, 2008b).…”

Mentoring Experience for Career Advancement: The perspectives of Black Women Academic Nurse Leaders

“…Mentoring offers invaluable exposure and creates networking opportunities essential for access to critical information and opportunities for career advancement ( Julion et al, 2019 ). However, the lack of mentors posed significant barriers to career advancement for aspiring ethnic minority healthcare leaders ( Julion et al, 2019 ; Silver, 2017 ).…”

“…Black women experience gender and race-based stereotypical discrimination ( Beckwith et al, 2016 ), making it very difficult to ascend to upper administrative positions even in women-dominated disciplines like nursing. Silver (2017) noted that in higher education and healthcare, white men and women occupy higher administrative-level positions where policies are formulated, while Black women and men and other People of color occupy lower-level administrative positions where policies are implemented. Mentoring in academia is essential for overcoming race-related barriers to advancement Davis (2009) .…”