Healthy Volunteers Can Be Phenotyped Using Cutaneous Sensitization Pain Models

Abstract

BackgroundHuman experimental pain models leading to development of secondary hyperalgesia are used to estimate efficacy of analgesics and antihyperalgesics. The ability to develop an area of secondary hyperalgesia varies substantially between subjects, but little is known about the agreement following repeated measurements. The aim of this study was to determine if the areas of secondary hyperalgesia were consistently robust to be useful for phenotyping subjects, based on their pattern of sensitization by the heat pain models.MethodsWe performed post-hoc analyses of 10 completed healthy volunteer studies (n = 342 [409 repeated measurements]). Three different models were used to induce secondary hyperalgesia to monofilament stimulation: the heat/capsaicin sensitization (H/C), the brief thermal sensitization (BTS), and the burn injury (BI) models. Three studies included both the H/C and BTS models.ResultsWithin-subject compared to between-subject variability was low, and there was substantial strength of agreement between repeated induction-sessions in most studies. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) improved little with repeated testing beyond two sessions. There was good agreement in categorizing subjects into ‘small area’ (1st quartile [<25%]) and ‘large area’ (4th quartile [>75%]) responders: 56–76% of subjects consistently fell into same ‘small-area’ or ‘large-area’ category on two consecutive study days. There was moderate to substantial agreement between the areas of secondary hyperalgesia induced on the same day using the H/C (forearm) and BTS (thigh) models.ConclusionSecondary hyperalgesia induced by experimental heat pain models seem a consistent measure of sensitization in pharmacodynamic and physiological research. The analysis indicates that healthy volunteers can be phenotyped based on their pattern of sensitization by the heat [and heat plus capsaicin] pain models.

A systematic review of peri‐operative melatonin

“…Any effect of peri-operative melatonin would vary with dosage, administration route and timing. A robust doseresponse relationship for melatonin has yet to be demonstrated in humans, which might be provided in non-clinical settings [38,39].…”

Endogenous Analgesia, Dependence, and Latent Pain Sensitization

“…It has been used extensively for pharmacodynamic research (Brennum et al, 2001, Werner et al, 2001, Dirks et al, 2002a, Dirks et al, 2002b, Werner et al, 2002a, Werner et al, 2002b, Dirks et al, 2003, Ravn et al, 2012, Ravn et al, 2013). Sensitization is transient, reversible and replicable (Werner et al, 2013). We recently reported that low dose naloxone (0.021 mg/kg, i.v.…”

Variability in Capsaicin-stimulated Calcitonin Gene-related Peptide Release from Human Dental Pulp

“…For example, studies using microdialysis to evaluate pharmacokinetics of dermal drug application reported between-subject variability to be the primary source of variability in the assay, complicating the measurement of drug bioequivalence (25,26). Human experimental pain models using capsaicin or heat to evoke secondary hyperalgesia also find that between-subject heterogeneity is a major source of variability (27). Inherent individual differences in pain neurotransmission create a challenge in the design of clinical/translational pain studies using human subjects or tissues.…”