Heat Recovery Potential and Hydrochemistry of Mine Water Discharges From Scotland’s Coalfields

Abstract

Prospective and operational mine water geothermal projects worldwide have faced challenges created by mine water chemistry (e.g., iron scaling, corrosion) and high expenditure costs (e.g., drilling or pumping costs) among others. Gravity fed or actively pumped drainages can be cheaper sources of low-carbon mine water heating when coupled with adequately sized heat exchanger and heat pump hardware. They also provide valuable chemical data to indicate mine water quality of associated coalfields. Field collection of temperature and flow rate data from mine water discharges across the Midland Valley of Scotland, combined with existing data for Coal Authority treatment schemes suggest that mine water heat pumps could provide a total of up to 48 MW of heat energy. Chemical characterisation of mine waters across the research area has created a valuable hydrochemical database for project stakeholders investigating mine water geothermal systems using boreholes or mine water discharges for heating or cooling purposes. Hydrochemical analytical assessment of untreated gravity discharges found that most are circumneutral, non-saline waters with an interquartile range for total iron of 2.0–11.6 mg/L. Stable isotope analysis indicates that the discharges are dominated by recent meteoric waters, but the origin of sulphate in mine waters is not as simple as coal pyrite oxidation, rather a more complex, mixed origin. Untreated gravity discharges contribute 595 kg/day of iron to Scottish watercourses; thus, it is recommended that when treatment schemes for mine water discharges are constructed, they are co-designed with mine water geothermal heat networks.

At the Sharp End of Fractured Granites: A Critical Geology for Critical Times

“…However, such energy recovery has a risk of induced seismicity, and the deep injection of surface water is currently under a planning moratorium in Scotland due to national bans on deep fluid injection associated with fracking (Scottish Government, 2016). Hot sedimentary aquifer schemes have been proposed for the Midland Valley (e.g., Scottish Government, 2013;Comerford et al, 2018), as well as shallow mine water heat recovery (Walls et al, 2022).…”

Mine water as a source of energy: an application in a coalfield in Laciana Valley (León, NW Spain)

“…Iron sulfides, which are often present in coal deposits, can be exposed and oxidize in mine voids when the mine is active, so when they are flooded, water quality can deteriorate. It has been shown that this leads to the formation of acidic waters, rich in iron and sulfates, or in the presence of carbonates, the waters can be hard and encrusting (Walls et al 2022 , 2021 ; Younger et al 2002 ). The discharging mine water after flooding an underground mine often must be treated, but its quality usually improves gradually over time, according to the effect known as ‘first flush’ (Wolkersdorfer et al 2022 ; Younger et al 2002 ).…”