Hedonic Consumption in Times of Stress: Reaping the Emotional Benefits Without the Self-Regulatory Cost

Abstract

Hedonic consumption is pleasant but can interfere with the capacity to self-regulate. In stressful moments, when self-regulation is arguably still important, individuals often indulge in hedonic consumption. In two experiments, we investigate whether hedonic consumption negatively affects self-regulation under moderately stressful conditions and whether selecting hedonic consumption under moderately stressful conditions is driven by high or low self-control. In both studies, participants were randomly exposed to a mental arithmetic task that was either completed under time pressure with performance feedback (moderate stress) or without time pressure and without feedback (no stress). Experiment 1 assigned participants to a hedonic (vs. neutral) consumption task and then measured impulse control via a color-word Stroop task. Experiment 2 measured self-control as a second independent variable and recorded hedonic (vs. neutral) consumption. The results show that moderate stress buffered the negative effect that hedonic consumption has on self-regulation under no stress conditions and that high rather than low self-control predicts hedonic over neutral consumption under stress. These findings indicate that hedonic consumption in response to moderate stress may be a strategic choice to reap the pleasure benefit of hedonic consumption while the costs to self-regulation are low.

How active and passive social media use affects impulse buying in Chinese college students? The roles of emotional responses, gender, materialism and self-control

“…When people feel enjoyment during social media usage, they buy products on impulse, and there is no significant difference between those with high selfcontrol and those with low self-control. The results are consistent with earlier research (Balleyer and Fennis, 2022), which claimed that positive emotions lead to less vigilance and thereby reduce selfregulation. When individuals experience enjoyment, those with high self-control are not significantly different from those with low selfcontrol in their ability to control impulsive spending.…”

Coping Mechanisms of Stress: The Impact on Online Purchase Impulsivity

“…These contradictory findings continue to spark debate among researchers and offer a promising field for further exploration of the intricate relationship between impulsivity and accomplishing self-satisfaction. Balleyer and Fennis (2022) stated that people utilize shopping and spending to cope with stress and emotions. However, the effects of this behavior on impulsivity and self-reward pursuit still need to be thoroughly researched.…”