Help or resistance? Product market competition and water information disclosure: evidence from China

Abstract

Purpose This paper investigates the relationship between product market competition and firms’ water information disclosure and how firms’ ownership type can affect this relationship in China, offering new insights into corporate water management. Design/methodology/approach The authors investigated 303 Chinese listed companies in highly water-sensitive industries to examine how product market competition influences corporate water information disclosure by subdividing the product market competition into market competition at the firm level and the industry competition intensity at the industry level. Findings The results show that there exists an inverted U-shaped relationship between industry competition and water information disclosure; enterprises with the highest market power in a mildly competitive industry are more willing to voluntarily disclose water information and play an industry benchmarking role. Further tests demonstrate that the relationship between industry competition intensity and water information disclosure is stronger for state-owned enterprises than for private enterprises. Research limitations/implications The current water resources regulations in China are relatively lax and the water risk awareness of firms is weak, which may affect the applicability of the results. In addition, water information disclosure research is a relatively new field and a quantitative index system for water information disclosure is still in the exploratory stage. Further developments, including the selection, definition and measuring methods of a water index are required. Practical implications The authors developed a new direction of enterprise water management activities from the perspective of market competition. Based on the market conditions in China, the authors also investigated the impact of the ownership type of the enterprises on the relationship between market competition and water information disclosure. Social implications The authors suggested that the government should improve laws and regulations and adopt incentive mechanisms to encourage enterprises to implement water resource management. In addition, the government should encourage high market status enterprises to actively fulfill their environmental responsibilities so that the entire industry is encouraged to follow suit. Originality/value This study represents an important development in the field of environmental accounting and is the first research on corporate water information disclosure; it also extends the research on the influence mechanisms of market competition on the environmental management practices of enterprises.

A review and synthesis of contemporary sustainability accounting research and the development of a research agenda

“…There is also evidence of mimetic isomorphism and consideration of competitor practices (Robertson & Samy, 2015; Wijethilake et al, 2017). The influence of industry competition has been inconclusive and some scholars have argued the relationship is non‐linear (Meng et al, 2019; Zhou et al, 2020).…”

Do boards practice what they preach on nonfinancial disclosure? Evidence from China on corporate water information disclosures

“…We control some other variables to test the robustness of our results to avoid the influence of unknown factors inside and outside the enterprise on water information disclosure. First, Zhou, Zhang, Chen, Zeng and Chen (2020) showed that the intensity of industry competition influences water information disclosure. Thus, we include the Herfindahl–Hirschman Index ( HHI ) to measure the intensity of competition in the industry.…”

Sustainability accounting, management and policy in China: recent developments and future avenues

“…Pan et al (2020) and Zhou et al (2019a) examined the impact of China’s unique political institutions on companies’ environmental performance and disclosure, enriching the understanding of companies’ environmental behaviors in transitioning countries. Zhou et al ’s (2019b) research is one of the few contemporary studies on companies’ information disclosure about water pollution. These studies uncover the role of prosecuted corrupt officials Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC) involved in environmental issues, which has been rarely explored in the extant literature.…”

“…Zhou et al (2019b) explored the role of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC) in dealing with environmental challenges. The authors sampled 457 CPPCC environmental proposals across 160 cities during the period 2013 to 2015 and found that CPPCC environmental proposals helped improve environmental quality as measured by air quality in the cities.…”