Reply:We read with great interest the findings described by Shi et al. They detected high levels of donor-derived CD56 þ , CD3 þ , and CD14 þ T cells in the first explanted liver grafts in both the short and long term after liver transplantation (LT). They concluded that these long-lived intragraft leukocytes in LT patients could cause long-term hematopoietic chimerism, challenging our conclusion that long-term blood chimerism is derived from hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells (HSPCs) in the liver, 1 although they also suggest the possibility that it may result from hematopoiesis of relocated donor HSPCs.The critical issue here is whether the mature leukocytes in the intragraft are really long-lived. Natural killer (NK) cells (CD56 þ ) are generally considered short-lived effector cells. Although it is still controversial, recent studies have demonstrated that NK cells have the ability to become long-lived memory cells and contribute to secondary immune responses. 2 The mechanisms for NK cell longevity are unclear, but these self-renewing capable NK cells are not just simple mature NK cell proliferation. In liver tissue, CD14 þ cells are mostly Kupffer cells with a lifespan of 3.8 days, which are generated and maintained by a high monocyte influx rate or local progenitor proliferation. 3 However, what the local progenitor cells are and where they are derived from are yet to be clarified.