As pediatric hospitalists, we often care for neonates and young infants <2 months of age that are admitted to the hospital because of concern for serious infection. Although there are certain clinical signs and symptoms that raise our concern for neonatal herpes simplex virus (HSV; eg, seizures, vesicular rash, critical illness), there is considerable variability in the management of this population when these provocative symptoms are absent. Should we test for HSV in all well-appearing newborns with fever? Or should there be an age cutoff below which all newborns are tested? If we perform testing, should we always start acyclovir? Should we obtain viral studies of mucosal surfaces routinely or only when we have a high level of suspicion? What role should HSV PCR from suspected HSV lesions of the skin, eye or mouth play, as opposed to viral culture? Under what circumstances is it safe to discontinue acyclovir after the CSF HSV PCR is negative? Neonatal HSV is rare, with only ∼1500 cases in the United States each year, 1 yet the consequences of delayed treatment are signifi cant.2 There is little controversy concerning the initiation of HSV testing for infants with clinical signs and symptoms suggestive of HSV. Empiric treatment with high-dose intravenous acyclovir is also not controversial because high-dose acyclovir has been the standard treatment for more than a decade and has a low side-effect profi le relative to the risk of untreated HSV infection.3,4 However, for infants without clinical signs of HSV, the decision to include empiric testing and treatment is less clear. Although a maternal history of fever and primary HSV infection are associated with neonatal HSV, 5 the absence of maternal history of known HSV is not helpful in predicting which infants should be evaluated for HSV infection. 6 Given that many of these infants will otherwise be admitted and started on empiric treatment of bacterial infection, what is the downside of adding on HSV testing and initiating acyclovir? Despite many advances in the diagnosis and treatment of neonatal HSV, considerable controversy still exists regarding which neonates and infants require testing and empiric acyclovir. Some experts have recommended that neonates only be tested and empirically treated if they have "HSV-specifi c" signs and symptoms, such as seizures, vesicles, sepsis-like illness, and/or cerebrospinal fl uid pleocytosis.