Catalyst and substrate studies have been performed on the rhodium-catalyzed asymmetric ring opening reaction. A working model is advanced that involves oxidative insertion with retention to form an organorhodium intermediate that then undergoes nucleophilic attack with inversion. Kinetic and competition experiments have uncovered evidence for a proton transfer step in the catalytic cycle that may activate both the allylrhodium intermediate and the nucleophile. We have also conducted experiments designed to understand which properties of the PPF-P t Bu2 ligand contribute to the high reactivities and enantioselectivities.W e have previously reported that chiral rhodium(I) catalysts induce ring opening oxa-and azabicyclic alkenes with a variety of soft nucleophiles such as alcohols, phenols, amines, anilines, malonates, and carboxylates in high yield and enantioselectivity (1-8). The products are generated by an S N 2Ј nucleophilic displacement of the bridgehead leaving group with inversion providing the 1,2-trans product as one regio-and diastereomer. The formation of the 1,2-trans products is atypical for ring opening reactions of oxabicyclic alkenes, which usually generate the syn-1,2 diastereomers via exo nucleophilic attack (1, 2). Furthermore, regio-and stereochemical results diverge from previously documented rhodium-catalyzed reactions with allylic carbonates (9-18). The observations obtained with oxabicyclic alkenes find little precedent when compared to other allylic functionalizations including those catalyzed by Pd (refs. 19 In this report we describe catalyst and substrate studies and advance a mechanistic working model that rationalizes the stereochemical outcome and other experimental observations (Scheme 1). We have also conducted experiments designed to understand the properties of the PPF-P t Bu 2 ligand that contribute to high reactivities and enantioselectivities.Experimental procedures and characterization data can be found in Supporting Text, which is published as supporting information on the PNAS web site.
Ligand Studies: Variations on the Josiphos Template and Other Ligand MotifsSeveral structural elements are present on the PPF scaffold that could contribute to its successful application in these reactions (51-53). PPF has elements of central and planar chirality as well as two phosphine atoms that differ both sterically and electronically. Two methods were used to determine the influence of the ligand on the rate. In cases where a significant difference in rate was observed, percent conversion vs. time, as determined by crude 1 H NMR, was used to quantify the reactivity of the catalyst. In cases where a more precise measurement of rate was desired, kinetic runs were performed.By comparing the reactivity and enantioselectivity of ligands 3 and 4, two trends emerge (Scheme 2). First, by increasing the steric bulk ( t Bu Ͼ Cy) the enantioselectivity is increased from 88% with 3 to 96% enantiomeric excess (ee) with the bulkier t Bu 2 P ligand 4. This increase in enantioselectivity comes at ...