N-doped carbon nanomaterials have received increased attention from electrochemists due to their applications in the metal-free electrocatalysis of important redox processes. In this work, a series of graphitized undoped and nitrogen-doped carbon electrodes prepared by thermal annealing of sputtered amorphous carbon films were prepared and characterized using a combination of X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and Raman spectroscopy. Adsorption of the surface-sensitive redox probe dopamine at each electrode surface was then studied using cyclic voltammetry and the results correlated to the physico-chemical characterisation. Results indicate that dopamine adsorption is influenced by both the nitrogen surface chemistry and the degree of graphitization of the carbon scaffold. N-doping, with predominantly graphitic-N sites, was found to increase adsorption of dopamine more than 6 fold on carbon surfaces when the introduction of N atoms did not result in substantial alterations to the sp 2 network. However, when an identical type and level of N-doping is accompanied by a significant increase in disorder in the carbon scaffold, adsorption is limited to levels comparable to those of nitrogen-free carbon. Density functional theory studies of dopamine adsorption on graphene and N-doped graphene model surfaces showed that dopamine interacts via π-stacking at the graphene surface. The Gibbs free energy of adsorption on N-doped graphenes were estimated at 12-13 kcal mol-1 , and found to be approximately twice that of undoped graphenes. Results suggest that chemical changes resulting from N-doping enhance adsorption; however, high coverage values depend on the availability of sites for π-stacking. Therefore, the structurally disruptive effects of N-incorporation can significantly depress the dopamine response by limiting the availability of basal sites, ultimately dominating the overall electrochemical response of the carbon electrode.