The biosynthesis of amino acid derivatives of animal origin in plants represents a promising frontier in synthetic biology, offering a sustainable and eco-friendly approach to enhancing the nutritional value of plant-based diets. This study leverages the versatile capabilities of Nicotiana benthamiana as a transient expression system to test a synthetic modular framework for the production of creatine, carnosine, and taurine-compounds typically absent in plants but essential for human health. By designing and stacking specialized synthetic modules, we successfully redirected the plant metabolic flux toward the synthesis of these amino acid derivatives of animal origin. Our results revealed the expression of a standalone creatine module resulted in the production of 2.3 μg/ g fresh weight of creatine in N. benthamiana leaves. Integrating two modules significantly carnosine yield increased by 3.8-fold and minimized the impact on plant amino acid metabolism compared to individual module application. Unexpectedly, introducing the taurine module caused a feedback-like inhibition of plant cysteine biosynthesis, revealing complex metabolic adjustments that can occur when introducing foreign pathways. Our findings underline the potential for employing plants as biofactories for the sustainable production of essential nutrients of animal origin.