Hierarchical structure and transfer mechanism to assess the scheduling-related risk in construction of prefabricated buildings: an integrated ISM–MICMAC approach

Abstract

PurposeUnder the background that engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contracting model is introduced to adapt to the highly fragmented characteristics of prefabricated construction, the schedule management of general contractor is faced with the challenge of dynamic transmission and interaction of construction scheduling-related risk. The purpose of this paper is to develop the hierarchy of prefabricated construction scheduling-related risks from the perspective of the general contractor, and to analyze the transmission mechanism between risks. The paper also aims to further distinguish the difference of the impact degree of scheduling-related risks, and provide reference for formulating the strategy to alleviate the construction delay.Design/methodology/approachBased on a review of the literature on prefabricated buildings, this paper identifies 22 scheduling-related risks in construction from the perspective of the general contractor. Semi-structured interviews were then conducted to obtain experts' views on the interrelationships among these risks. Following this, their overall structure was determined by using a hierarchical structure established by using interpretive structural modeling (ISM), and Matrice d'Impacts Croisés Multiplication Appliqués à un Classement (MICMAC) technique was applied to classify them into four groups according to their driving and dependence powers.FindingsThe results indicate that the 22 scheduling-related risks in construction followed the inherent path of step-by-step transmission, and all of them could cause different degrees of delays in prefabricated construction. Among them, general experience in contracting projects, the use of emerging technologies and the completeness of the relevant standards and specifications were strong drivers of scheduling delays in construction, and should be prioritized by the general contractor in schedule management. The transitive link between scheduling risks can guide them in developing prevention strategies.Research limitations/implicationsData quality and reliability risks are the major drawbacks of semi-structured interviews. These were minimized by engaging experts with rich theoretical and hands-on experience in prefabricated construction projects. The hierarchical model only reflects static influence relationships, and so dynamic interactions among scheduling-related risks should be studied in future.Originality/valueThe primary value of this study is in its development of a hierarchical model by using the integrated ISM–MICMAC approach that reflects the interaction between scheduling risks in the construction of prefabricated buildings. The hierarchy of these risks and the results of a “driving-dependence power” analysis can guide the general contractor in taking targeted preventive measures to avoid scheduling delays in the construction of prefabricated buildings.

What Hinders Internet of Things (Iot) Adoption in the Chinese Construction Industry: A Mixed-Method

“…Iqbal et al (2023) examined the critical success factors of energy-efficient supply chains in the construction industry by integrating the Delphi, ISM, and MICMAC method. Fan et al (2022) used an integrated ISM-MICMAC approach to assess the scheduling-related risk in the construction of prefabricated buildings. Thereby, multi-criteria analysis is postulated as a powerful tool to aid decision-makers in better selecting their options in a wide range of construction problems.…”

Quality Evaluation Approach for Prefabricated Buildings Using Ant Colony Algorithm and Simulated Annealing Algorithm to Optimize the Projection Pursuit Model

“…Ranjbar et al discovered the risk indicators of hazardous, earthquake-induced structures using the modified, hierarchical, fuzzy TOP-SIS approach [14]. In order to assess the risk of assembled risk in building construction and scheduling, as well as to look at the method by which risks are transmitted, Fan et al used hierarchical analysis [15]. The sustainability of SIP buildings in rural China was evaluated by Bai et al based on AHP-gray correlation analysis, and they offer a guide to help builders select the optimal building structure for rural China [16].…”

Quality Risk Assessment of Prefabricated Steel Structural Components during Production Using Fuzzy Bayesian Networks: A Case Study in China

“…Liu et al, 2018), controlling project investment risks (X.-J. Li, 2020), and conducting risk assessments during the construction phase (Fan et al, 2023;Pervez et al, 2022;Tatari, 2023). Additionally, studies on risk management across different stages of prefabricated steel structure construction have become more comprehensive (Y.…”