High-heeled shoes and musculoskeletal injuries: a narrative systematic review

Abstract

ObjectivesTo conduct the first systematic review from an epidemiological perspective regarding the association between high-heeled shoe wear and hallux valgus, musculoskeletal pain, osteoarthritis (OA) and both first-party and second-party injury in human participants without prior musculoskeletal conditions.SettingA systematic review of international peer-reviewed scientific literature across seven major languages.Data sourcesSearches were conducted on seven major bibliographic databases in July 2015 to initially identify all scholarly articles on high-heeled shoes. Supplementary manual searches were conducted. Titles, abstracts and full-text articles were sequentially screened to identify all articles assessing epidemiological evidence regarding the association between high-heeled shoe wear and hallux valgus, musculoskeletal pain, OA and both first-party and second-party injury in human participants without prior musculoskeletal conditions. Standardised data extraction and quality assessment (Threats to Validity tool) were conducted.Primary and secondary outcome measuresMusculoskeletal pain or OA as assessed by clinical diagnosis or clinical assessment tool. First-party or second-party injury.Results644 unique records were identified, 56 full-text articles were screened and 18 studies included in the review. Four studies assessed the relationship with hallux valgus and three found a significant association. Two studies assessed the association with OA and neither found a significant association. Five studies assessed the association with musculoskeletal pain and three found a significant association. Eight studies assessed first-party injury and seven found evidence of a significant injury toll associated with high-heeled shoes. One study provided data on second-party injury and the injury toll was low.ConclusionsHigh-heeled shoes were shown to be associated with hallux valgus, musculoskeletal pain and first-party injury. No conclusive evidence regarding OA and second-party injury was found. Societal and clinical relevance of these findings is discussed. Concern is expressed about the expectation to wear high-heeled shoes in some work and social situations and access by children.

Cultural and Aesthetic Analysis of Some of the Most Daring Celebrity Fashion Trends

“…This sex appeal is supported by scientific evidence (Barnish, Morgan, & Barnish, 2017;Guéguen, 2015). Of course, high heels are bad for our health (Barnish et al, 2017;Barnish & Barnish, 2016;Cronin, 2014), but surely that is a choice we can make as adults. Most female celebrities wear high heels for every, or almost every, red carpet appearance or similar.…”

Boobs Out! A Perspective on Fashion, Sexuality and Equality

“…Before we reach any conclusions, substantial further research is required into the potential safety risks to others posed by various glamorous items of women's fashion, and also the extent to which other people are having to be deliberately careful to avoid being injured by these hazards. Definitely, women's clothing and its associated risks are not handled in policy in the same way as similar items that are not worn by women, as discussed for example by Barnish and Barnish (2016) in the context of the differential handling of stilettos and knives. This situation is mirrored across a wide range of items such as trains and sequins.…”

“…Possible, initiatives could be considered to allow men greater opportunities to show their individual personalities through what they wear, for example a broader color palate or more expressive waistcoats, as well as trying to develop some options in menswear that are more sexually provocative for women. Any dress code can lead to equality issues, however issues are most notable when one gender is required to wear something that harms their health (Barnish & Barnish, 2016), while the other is…”

The Politics of Women’s Fashion in the Cultural West: A Perspective

“…Indeed, fashion itself operates through socially normative processes, as discussed in the work of Barnish (Barnish & Barnish, 2016;. Indeed, even in modern Western society, it is culturally accepted to require both men and women to wear particular items in certain settings.…”