High-quality journalism in the face of Donald Trump’s theory of electoral fraud: the information strategy of the media in the 2020 US presidential election

Abstract

The institutional political crisis is posited to be a great risk facing twenty-first-century societies. The instability of democracy, the increase in misinformation in electoral processes, and distrust by citizens are facts that are confirmed by studies such as The Economist Intelligence Unit (2018) or Freedom in the World (2018). In the context of the most recent US elections (3-Nov-2020), President Donald Trump initiated a dialog focused on an allegation of electoral fraud that mobilized the masses and culminated in an assault on the Capitol. In parallel, Twitter endorses the role of journalism (@ABC, @AP, @CBSNews, @CNN, @FoxNews, @NBCNews, and @Reuters) as a gatekeeper to lies on the Internet. The aim of this study is to determined how the media treated the electoral process on their Twitter accounts, analyze the strategies they followed to combat Trump’s fallacy, and verify the extent to which they contributed or not to the spread of the conspiracy theory. Using a general sample of tweets (n1 = 3,577), we applied a comparative content analysis methodology with a three-pronged approach (quantitative-qualitative-discursive) based on the use of keyword indicators (n2 = 34,430). The results confirm that the media offered verified content on the electoral process, using different sources and avoiding reproduction of Donald Trump’s delegitimization speech. In general, they engaged in a fight against the theory of electoral fraud, against disinformation, and against the polarization of citizens, which are factors that have marked a scenario of doubt about the future of democracy.

Facing Conspiracies: Biden’s Counter-Speech to Trumpist Messages in the Framework of the 2020 US Elections

“…Specifically, the characteristics of Twitter are insightful to understand why Biden chose several issues and strategies on public administration to develop a storytelling on legitimacy. Nevertheless, the huge impact of Trump's digital rhetoric at the international level [69] demands studies that compare the ability of Biden and legacy media to counteract his discourses beyond the US [70].…”

Capítulo 4. La lucha contra la desinformación en la sociedad post-pandemia: un reto para el periodismo y más allá

“…Su finalidad es desestabilizar la democracia en un momento de crisis global (Levitsky;Ziblatt, 2018). Se produce entonces una eclosión de noticias falsas que han empoderado las políticas antidemocráticas (Pérez Curiel et al, 2021) y que igualan al número de noticias profesionales de medios acreditados (Wooley; Howard, 2016). Un ejemplo son las teorías conspirativas lanzadas por Donald Trump que acusan a China del mal endémico, o el anuncio de medicamentos sin respaldo científico, (Chadwick;Cereceda, 2020).…”

Las elecciones presidenciales de EE. UU. (2020) en las portadas de la prensa española

“…Sin embargo, al momento de finalizar esta investigación escasamente se había investigado y publicado de forma sistemática al respecto desde el prisma de su tratamiento informativo en los medios de comunicación, exceptuando algún trabajo, como el de Pérez-Curiel et al (2021). Y, menos aún, en cuanto a la cobertura que a este evento le dieron los medios españoles, por lo que este trabajo pretende ser una primera aportación a este panorama, teniendo en cuenta, como hemos indicado, la importancia que han tenido estos comicios electorales en todo el mundo.…”