High Welfare Matching Markets via Descending Price

Abstract

We consider design of monetary mechanisms for two-sided matching. Mechanisms in the tradition of the deferred acceptance algorithm, even in variants incorporating money, tend to focus on the criterion of stability. Instead, in this work we seek a simple auction-inspired mechanism with social welfare guarantees. We consider a descending-price mechanism called the Marshallian Match, proposed (but not analyzed) by Waggoner and Weyl (2019). We show the Marshallian Match has constant price of anarchy when all values for potential matches are positive. This result extends to models with costs for acquiring information about one's values, and also to matching on hypergraphs. With possiblynegative valuations, which capture e.g. job markets, the problem becomes harder. We introduce notions of approximate stability and show that they have beneficial welfare implications. However, the main problem of proving constant factor welfare guarantees in "ex ante stable equilibrium" remains open.