Highly Overlapping Winter Diet in Two Sympatric Lemming Species Revealed by DNA Metabarcoding

Abstract

Sympatric species are expected to minimize competition by partitioning resources, especially when these are limited. Herbivores inhabiting the High Arctic in winter are a prime example of a situation where food availability is anticipated to be low, and thus reduced diet overlap is expected. We present here the first assessment of diet overlap of high arctic lemmings during winter based on DNA metabarcoding of feces. In contrast to previous analyses based on microhistology, we found that the diets of both collared (Dicrostonyx groenlandicus) and brown lemmings (Lemmus trimucronatus) on Bylot Island were dominated by Salix while mosses, which were significantly consumed only by the brown lemming, were a relatively minor food item. The most abundant plant taxon, Cassiope tetragona, which alone composes more than 50% of the available plant biomass, was not detected in feces and can thus be considered to be non-food. Most plant taxa that were identified as food items were consumed in proportion to their availability and none were clearly selected for. The resulting high diet overlap, together with a lack of habitat segregation, indicates a high potential for resource competition between the two lemming species. However, Salix is abundant in the winter habitats of lemmings on Bylot Island and the non-Salix portion of the diets differed between the two species. Also, lemming grazing impact on vegetation during winter in the study area is negligible. Hence, it seems likely that the high potential for resource competition predicted between these two species did not translate into actual competition. This illustrates that even in environments with low primary productivity food resources do not necessarily generate strong competition among herbivores.

The ecologist's field guide to sequence‐based identification of biodiversity

“…), this approach is now extensively used by ecologists for assessing the diet of herbivores (Soininen et al . ), carnivores (Deagle, Kirkwood & Jarman ) and omnivores (De Barba et al . ).…”

Sedimentary ancient DNA from Lake Skartjørna, Svalbard: Assessing the resilience of arctic flora to Holocene climate change

“…Finally, using the ecotag program (Yoccoz et al, 2012), sequences were compared with a local taxonomic reference library containing 2445 sequences of 815 arctic (Sønstebø et al, 2010) and 835 boreal (Willerslev et al, 2014) vascular taxa as well as 455 bryophytes (Soininen et al, 2015), and assigned to the relevant taxon. Using the local reference library confers the advantage of a more accurate match with species that are found in the local environment.…”

How much is enough? Effects of technical and biological replication on metabarcoding dietary analysis

“…The advent of DNA‐based molecular tools for the identification of complex multitaxa samples, that is metabarcoding, has greatly renewed the interest in dietary studies, particularly due to the high taxonomic resolution offered by this approach (e.g., De Barba et al., ; Kartzinel & Pringle, ; Lopes et al., ). This has been especially relevant to species whose diet is particularly difficult to study, either due to their secretive behaviour (e.g., Shehzad et al., ; Soininen et al., ) or due to difficulties to identify prey in dietary remains such as stomach contents, regurgitates and scats (e.g., Arrizabalaga‐Escudero et al., ; Kaunisto, Roslin, Sääksjärvi, & Vesterinen, ; Mollot et al., ). However, despite its increasingly widespread use, uncertainties and potential biases associated with the quantification of diets based on metabarcoding are still not well understood, requiring a detailed enquiry on how results are affected by different methodological options (Alberdi, Aizpurua, Gilbert, & Bohmann, ; Nielsen et al., ).…”