HIV testing practices among black primary care physicians in the United States

Abstract

BackgroundThe Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends routine HIV testing in all healthcare settings, but it is unclear how consistently physicians adopt the recommendation. Making the most of each interaction between black physicians and their patients is extremely important to address the HIV health disparities that disproportionately afflict the black community. The goal of this survey-based study was to evaluate the perceptions and practices of black, primary care physicians regarding HIV testing.MethodsA physician survey was administered at the 2010 National Medical Association Annual Convention, via online physician panels, and by email. Physician eligibility criteria: black race; practicing at least 1 year in the US; practice comprised of at least 60% adults and 20% black patients. Contingency tables and ordinary least squares regression were used for comparisons and statistical analyses. A Chi-square test compared percentages of physicians who gave a particular response and a t-test compared the means of values provided by physicians.ResultsPhysicians over-estimated HIV prevalence and believed that HIV is a crisis in the black community, yet reported that only 34% of patients were HIV tested in the past year. Physicians reported that 67% of those patients tested did so due to a physician recommendation. Physicians who were younger, female, obstetricians/gynecologists, and had a higher proportion of black, low-socioeconomic status, and Medicaid patients reported higher testing rates. Most testing was risk-based rather than routine, and three of the five most commonly reported barriers to testing were related to disease stigma and perceived value judgments. Physicians reported that in-office patient informational materials, increased media attention, additional education and training on HIV testing, government mandates requiring routine testing, and accurate pre-packed tests would most help them test more frequently for HIV.ConclusionsIn this sample of black, primary care physicians, HIV testing practices differed according to physician characteristics and practice demographics, and overall reported testing rates were low. More physician education and training around testing guidelines is needed to enable more routine testing, treatment, and long-term management of patients with HIV.

Brief Sexual Histories and Routine HIV/STD Testing by Medical Providers

“…2,4,5 Routine HIV testing with linkage to care is a key strategy for early diagnosis, treatment, and reduction of ongoing HIV transmission. Yet rates of routine HIV testing among providers remain suboptimal ( < 40% of providers surveyed reported routine HIV testing with their patients), 6 despite recommendations that providers in health care settings perform routine HIV testing for patients aged 13-64 years 7 or ages 15-65 years 8 and that annual HIV testing occur for persons at high risk of acquiring HIV. 7,8 Recent data suggest that more frequent HIV screenings every 3-6 months may be appropriate for some subgroups of young MSM who are at increased risk.…”

HIV Testing Among Adults with Mental Illness in the United States

“…7 In contrast, providers who perceive their patients to be at high risk of HIV perform more frequent testing. 34 Mentally ill individuals are more likely than others to engage in high-risk behaviors associated with HIV transmission, including unprotected sexual intercourse, injection drug use, and sex with multiple partners. 35,36 Recognition of these risk factors may prompt patients to seek and for providers to offer HIV testing.…”

Compliance with a New York State 2010 HIV Testing Law: Is There Racial/Ethnic Bias in HIV Testing? Experience of Monroe County, New York, 2012

“…Prior studies have shown that HIV testing rates are higher for patients receiving health services from obstetricians/gynecologists. [33][34][35] As others have discussed, during a routine gynecological exam, it may be easier to recommend HIV testing in the context of general screening for sexually transmitted infections since sexual activity is assumed. Pregnancy may also increase the likelihood of HIV testing, given that the CDC and the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology recommend opt-out HIV testing for pregnant women.…”