Homophily and Polarization in Twitter Political Networks: A Cross-Country Analysis

Abstract

Homophily, the tendency of people to have ties with those who are similar, is a fundamental pattern to understand human relations. As such, the study of homophily can provide key insights into the flow of information and behaviors within political contexts. Indeed, some degree of polarization is necessary for the functioning of liberal democracies, but too much polarization can increase the adoption of extreme political positions and create democratic gridlock. The relationship between homophilous communication ties and political polarization is thus fundamental because it affects a pillar of democratic regimes: the need for public debate where divergent ideas and interests can be confronted. This research compares the degree of homophily and political polarization in Catalan MPs’ Twitter mentions network to Dutch MPs’ Twitter mentions network. Exponential random graph models were employed on a one-year sample of mentions among Dutch MPs (<em>N</em> = 7,356) and on a one-year, three-month sample of mentions among Catalan MPs (<em>N</em> = 19,507). Party polarization was measured by calculating the external–internal index of both Twitter mentions networks. Results reveal that the mentions among Catalan MPs are much more homophilous than those among the Dutch MPs. Indeed, there is a positive relationship between the degree of MPs’ homophilous communication ties and the degree of political polarization observed in each network.

Right-Wing Twitter Users in France Exhibit Growing Homophily Compared With Left and Center Users

“…This study raises concerns, particularly considering the positive correlation between homophilous communication ties and political polarization, ultimately fostering the adoption of extreme political positions (Esteve-Del-Valle, 2022). Combining the findings of this article with heightened homophily within right-wing circles beyond the digital realm potentially contributes to increased polarization, the formation of echo chambers, and resistance to diverse perspectives, thereby shaping the socio-political landscape in ways that warrant careful consideration.…”

Homophily in voting behavior: Evidence from preferential voting

“…For instance, less educated people, women, or blue‐collar workers are often highly under‐represented (see Table 1). These under‐represented groups may feel that no one is defending their interests, which could increase social grievances, and potentially induce some voters to adopt extreme political positions (Esteve‐Del‐Valle, 2022). Previous findings and our own results suggest that homophily plays a role in voters' decision‐making.…”