Hospital Architecture in Spain and Italy: Gaps Between Education and Practice

Abstract

Aim The research sheds light on the challenges and limitations of Spanish and Italian hospital design by looking at the gaps between education and practice. Background Hospital design plays an important role in providing high-quality and cost-effective facilities for any healthcare system. Spain and Italy face contemporary challenges (i.e., elderly population, staff retention, and obsolete healthcare facilities) and have similar issues of life expectancy, health expenditure, hospital beds provision, and decentralized tax-financed healthcare systems. Method A cross-sectional, mixed-method study was used. This involved two different data collection strategies and analysis for each area of investigation: (i) education and (ii) practice. For the former, educational programs were reviewed via a web search; for the latter, an online survey of 53 architectural/engineering offices involved in hospital design was conducted. Results Hospital design education is limited to 0/58 in Spanish and 2/60 courses in Italian universities, although each country offers three postgraduate courses. The practitioners’ survey shows that even though their offices have a long history of healthcare design, only 48% in Spain and 60% in Italy have received specific university training. Office staff lack employees with medical backgrounds, which hinders any partnership between health and design fields either for design practice or the education fields. Laws, national regulations, technical guidelines, and previous experience are the most useful information sources, while international scientific publications appear underused by practitioners. Conclusions Italian and Spanish healthcare architecture could be improved by promoting multidisciplinary teams (in practice and education) and improving the education offer by tailoring it to national needs.

Flexibility during the COVID-19 Pandemic Response: Healthcare Facility Assessment Tools for Resilient Evaluation

“…Hospital buildings should have the capability to accommodate alteration of functions and not just designed rigidly to serve a specific purpose. In fact, such approaches can only be addressed if a participatory design and multidisciplinary cooperation between different fields, disciplines and professions is in place [ 48 , 49 ]. The needs of different stakeholders and users can be met in a flexible physical built environment that accommodates different activities such as when designing cancer care facilities [ 50 ].…”

“…The flexibility principle is not commonly considered nor used by practitioners, however it is used in various hospitals worldwide without intentionally aiming for flexibility [ 20 , 49 ]. We demonstrated using the original assessment tool that only one in seven of the most advanced healthcare facilities scored higher than 80%.…”

Staff retention – the hidden issue in design and organizing of healthcare facilities

“…An ongoing challenge is to develop training curricula for healthcare staff that enables a focus on clinical aspects combined with a multidisciplinary understanding of working and wellness conditions. It also is concerned with how design and management of healthcare facilities is addressed in the education and training of architects, engineers, economists, managers and several more professions (Azzopardi-Muscat et al, 2020;Cambra-Rufino et al, 2021;Gola et al, 2020).…”

Evaluation of the Results of a Periodic Environmental Biosecurity Assessment Program on Air Quality in Controlled Environment Rooms of Hospitals

“…These microorganisms can be transported by air and subsequently deposited on materials and surfaces and can enter the patient’s body during intraoperative procedures and cause HAIs (Perdelli et al, 2006; Prussin & Marr, 2015; Wagenvoort et al, 1993). To achieve quality and safety of patients, a multidisciplinary collaboration is necessary for the design and maintenance of controlled environment rooms and thus obtain correct indoor air quality (Cambra-Rufino et al, 2021). Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) systems should be specially designed, validated, and maintained to keep the number of particles and biological aerosols in the air below the recommended standards in order to reduce HAIs (Perdelli et al, 2006; Ulrich et al, 2008).…”